|
|
Mostly Cloudy ~ |
|
Bullying: a case of boys will be boys?Posted Tuesday, July 29, 2008, at 11:34 PM
The Oprah Show today featured the tragic story of a two young men who were once on youth baseball teams -- one of them is now dead and one is in prison, convicted of the other's murder.
From what I gathered, there was apparently a conflict between the two on the baseball field one day and the one boy became angry and struck the other one with a baseball bat, killing him. The father of the victim told Oprah that it was wrong for his son to tease the other boy (which apparently precipitated the baseball bat incident) however, he didn't feel his son deserved to be killed for it. And I agree. But what I don't agree with is how society tends to focus on the outcome of these tragic stories and fails to address the cause -- bullying. First of all, if we're going to discuss cases like the one that appeared on Oprah today, we need to separate the story into two parts. On the one side, you have the victim whose life was tragically cut short. This young man is dead. It's horrible and it shouldn't have happened. On the other side, you have the issue of bullying and what it does to the child on the receiving end, not that it justifies their actions. Before I say anything else, I want to make it clear that I am not a psychologist or any kind of expert whatsoever. I only speak from what I know personally. That is that being on the receiving end of bullying is not fun. We've all heard it said (primarily by the parents of the bully) that "boys will be boys" or "girls will be girls." Well I'm sorry, that doesn't serve as much comfort for the kid who's hold up in his or her room, in tears and terrified to go to school. Fortunately for me, it wasn't that severe. Some kids are stronger than others and having family or friends who support you makes a big difference. But what about those kids who aren't good at expressing their feelings, who bottle everything up until it explodes in one single moment of rage? This leads to school shootings and unfortunately to incidents similar to the one that was featured on Oprah. I congratulate state leaders who have recently begun to address the issue of bullying. It's a real issue that needs to be addressed and it's not going to go away. School administrators need to wake up and recognize the problem. Why not require students to take a course on the subject? Teachers too need to be on the lookout for this type of behavior. I can't tell you how many times in high school and junior high I would walk down the hallway and see kids victimized and not a teacher in sight. Get out of your classrooms and monitor the hallways, teachers. Once classes begin and students are inside the classrooms, again teachers need to be diligent to squash this type of behavior when they see it. Teachers: get control of your classrooms. And finally, to the victims themselves: take control of the situation. Stand up for yourself but in a calm and intelligent manner. Ask the bully "why are you doing this to me?" "What have I done to deserve this?" Tell them they are hurting your feelings and ask them to stop. If that doesn't work, don't you be afraid to march yourself right down to the principal's office and tell them you are being picked on. If people want to accuse you of being a tattle-tale, so be it. If the bully is sitting in detention or better yet, if he or she is on out-of-school suspension, great! That's where there type of behavior belongs. Everyone is different and no one deserves to be made fun of. I think the character "Thumper" from the movie Bambi said it best: "If you can't say nothin' nice, don't say nothin' at all." Comments Showing most recent comments first [Show in chronological order instead] |
Hot topics Sorry for the delay(0 ~ 11:38 PM, Oct 29)
Did you see it?
Roller Derby King
Stop lying to us
Squirrel crossing
|
Our son has come home more times then I wish to remember very upset by kids picking on him. I have talked to the school, they say something to the bully,it helps for a few days and then goes right back to the same old thing. We have also talked to the parents which deny that their child would do anything like that.Why can't kids just get along or atleast keep their mouths shut and go on about their own business. I have taught my kids to not make fun of anyone else but how do I keep teaching that when they get picked on day after day?
I know exactly what you are saying. I was picked on in school and I'm sure it had something to do with my personality today.
Thank you Mr. Coats for this forum to express our feeling's on this and many other subjects.
If there's one thing that I know, bullying isn't "boys will be boys." In fact, most of the bullying I endured while in school was from girls. Why? Because I was quiet and kept to myself and for kids with poor self-esteem, narcissistic and other personality disorders and problems at home I was a perfect target. As a child growing up it's hard to understand that your peers are abusing you because they don't feel good about themselves. It's life altering and the child usually ends up with their own self-esteem problems or turns to lashing out into adulthood. And to think of the abuse their own children will go through is heart wrenching.
I completely agree that school administrators need to wake up. Let's face it, one school counselor is NOT enough to combat these problems. If they knew how often the abuse went on, how many were sexually or physically abused at home they'd have been appalled. I know of the four years at SP the school counselor only spoke with me once during my senior year about school and home life and by that time the damage had already been done but just hearing her words "It's not your fault" was life-altering. By the time I got into the work force I became a prime target by abusive managers until one day I finally snapped and told the abuser just how evil she really was. As she sat in tears listening to me tell her how she makes me and others feel I realized she was just a miserable person with a personality disorder. But it took more than 22 years for me to get the courage up to do such a thing and it didn't just give me anxiety and panic disorder but it also made me a very cynical individual. It's not as easy as saying "suck it up" but when such a situation occurs it is empowering. It shouldn't have to get to that point, however.
Instead of investing millions on sports I think we should take that money and invest it into the well-being of the children. Is playing basketball going to affect their life as much as having a counselor available to talk to them about their abuse at home and school? Absolutely not. Abused children often grow up to continue the cycle of behavior if they don't receive the therapy and training they need.
I've heard numerous people who probably never endured bullying in all their time (likely because they were the bully) say that creating therapy and help to combat bullying is a waste of money, we need to teach our children to "have some guts." Try teaching that to a kid who goes to school every day getting beat up, gum put in their hair, rumors spread and degraded on a daily basis. You can't teach an abused dog not to be afraid of a raised hand and if you do, the only result is violence. Some children with anxiety/panic disorder, home abuse, etc. simply can not employ the tactics of confrontation. It shouldn't have to just be about the kid learning to confront people but it should also be about the abuser being stopped.
The fact is that this issue is a LOT deeper than telling a kid to get some guts, it starts at home and at school and we should be investing far more in our children's well being than in whether or not they can dribble a ball. Until these priorities are straight and we address all of the issues, this tragedy will continue to happen.
Exactly...it all starts at home with the parents. More than likely, the bullyers (or "taunters) come from the same type of parents. This behavior needs corrected AT HOME.
Yes it all does start at home when the parents do not punish kids anymore. There is nothing that a nice little swat on the butt cannot solve.
You know... I have two boys. The oldest is 5, is autistic and for the last two years went to a developmental preschool. For about two months my son started to change. He didnt want to go to school, he was in a foul mood when I picked him up but then he finally told us. Two boys at school were picking on him. So as a good parent, the teacher was addressed with this concern. Her response... They aren't bullying him... their taunting him. They know if they touch him that he will go from 0 - 60 in seconds. So... When did taunting not count as bullying? And because of this my son was disciplined at school and home because of his behaviours and foul atitude. Then one day I picked my son up from daycare and he wouldn't even look at me. I tried for over a half an hour to get him to talk to me. And when he did, he told me he was a failure and was not allowed to play with the kids at school. So of course I was upset and told my son that it was ok... he was now on summer vaction and my son never went back to that school.
I don't beleive "boys will be boys" but I do know something... my son is not going to pay the price for someone elses bad parenting and not teaching their kids manners, to be polite, and to respect those around you. Luckily this year as my son starts Kindergarten, Deer Meadow has given me hope in knowing that they will not tolerate this behavior. We could go on and on pushing the blame but in all honesty doesn't it start at home? Our kids look up to us as role modles and if that means keeping yourself in check then do what you have to do... but I'm the parent that wont sit back and let it happen.
Setting aside teachers for a moment, who really have a lot of other things to do and, in a big city school setting, the bullies are often tough gang members with a propensity to violence, how about the bully's father and the coach of the team. You mean to tell me they did not know what a s**t he was. "Victim" my foot. They know and often encourage it. That behavior can be casually observed. "Trash talk" and physical bullying have been tolerated and encouraged by coaches and practiced by athletes, first in the pros and then at all levels as younger athletes emulate it. It demeans the players and the games themselves. Probably was a good hitter. Ironic, is it not, that he died by the bat? In Indiana, there is a defense to that. In fact, it is a crime to provoke someone beyond reason.
PTSD is much like ADHD wai to overdiagnosed ad there is a possibility of being a made up thing.
Greetings;
A big thanks to Mr. Coates for his article on bullying in the schools. Although I didn't see the Oprah show, I'm aware from personal experience that bullying is a serious problem in this country. Many people don't realize that the emotional harm done by bullying, which is a form of psychological abuse, can equal the emotional damage done by rape, torture, war and other forms of sexual and physical abuse.
In 2004 I became the target of a workplace bully at my place of employment, Saint Alphonsus Regional Medical Center in Boise, Idaho. St. Alphonsus is a part of the Trinity Health system. After more than 2 and a half years of being bullied I had to resign and find a safer working environment. In the meantime I was diagnosed with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and had become partially disabled by the bullying. Fortunately I sought treatment early and was able to completely regain my normal function after leaving that toxic work environment.
I appreciate Mr Coates encouraging those who are the victims of bullies to report it. However in the workplace that doesn't necessarily help. Although a professional at my place of employment diagnosed me as being injured there with PTSD, nothing was done to address the problem and protect me from additional injury. The treatment I received after reporting the injury to my emplyer I had to get myself. The medical center did not offer me any treatment for PTSD.
When I reported the PTSD injury to different members of management, which I did numerous times over a period of nearly two years, the responses I received were orders to not talk about the injury with my co-workers and to lie about the injury if anyone asked. The employee relations manager responded to one report, reminding him of the PTSD injury, by threatening to terminate me and the Respiratory Care Department manager, the dept. where I worked, claimed that the injury was "petty." At no time did anyone in management actually respond addressing the injury.
You would think that if any employer would address bullying and its health and safety threats to people in the community it would be a medical center, but not Saint Alphonsus. I know of others who had similar experiences there so my ordeal was not unique. I've been told that this is a problem throughout the entire Trinity Health system, and a comnplaint about the bullying and subsequent negligent and unresponsive management I sent to a vice-president at Trinity Health, which was ignored, confirms that report.
I have more information about my experience in an April 11 entry on my blog at www.leonardnolt.blogspot.com and will be adding another within the next two weeks.
Again my thanks to Mr. Coates for his aritcle.
Leonard Nolt
leonardnolt@aol.com