"Way back in 1958, my neighbor said, 'Why don't you get together some of your friends and start a club?'" she said. "There were eight of us … I'm the only original member left."
On Thursday, past and current members of the Merry Jills -- now known as the Merry J's -- gathered at the Final Approach Bistro in Greencastle to share memories over brunch and celebrate the club's 50th anniversary.
The club now boasts an average membership of 20.
Pershing read some notes from the group's history.
"In 1960 we had our Christmas party at DePauw," she said. "They served us turkey plates for $2 apiece."
The major fundraisers for the group in 1963 were a Tupperware party and a bake sale -- which many of the members recalled. That was also the year the club's Christmas party was held despite a snow and ice storm -- and a member transported refreshments to Pershings' house on a sled.
The club's financial beginnings were humble: The November 1970 report showed $1.84 in its coffers.
Betty Fox, who joined the club in 1959, offered an idea about why the bank account grew so slowly.
"Our dues were 10 cents a month," she said. "They've really gone up a lot … now they're 25 cents."
"Our families have grown up together," she said.
Elaine Huber, who has been a Merry J since 1987, said she has enjoyed getting to know people from all walks of life and backgrounds.
"These are people we never would have met if it hadn't been for this club," she said.
Huber remembered a time many years ago when her young granddaughter helped the club construct a teddy bear-themed float for the Putnam County 4-H Fair parade.
"She must have been 10," Huber said. "We were lining up, and she ran up the parade route and back. She said, 'No problem, we're gonna win.' And we did. She's graduating from college now, and she still talks about helping the homemaker ladies with the float."
Norma Hurst is the current president of the Merry J's.
"It's great to have people come here and share their stories," she said.