[Nameplate] Mostly Cloudy ~ 72°F  
High: 70°F ~ Low: 46°F
Sunday, May 1, 2016

Rove, Dean bring lively debate to DePauw

Saturday, September 12, 2009

By Alex Turco/The DePauw-- Howard Dean, former chairman of the Democratic National Convention and former governor of Vermont, right, and Karl Rove, former Senior Advisor and Deputy Chief of Staff to former President George W. Bush, speak at DePauw University, Sept. 11, 2009. [Order this photo]
GREENCASTLE -- In the 23-year history of the Ubben Lecture series at DePauw, no debate had been conducted prior to Friday night's event featuring Howard Dean and Karl Rove.

In what was described by moderator Dr. Bruce Stinebrickner as a "spirited, interesting, and, above all, informative event," the pair of political heavy hitters did not disappoint a packed house in Kresge Auditorium.

Rove, the former chief political advisor to President George W. Bush, drew some laughs early when he tried to switch sides when he realized he was on the audience's left side.

With his opening statement, each man defined his stance on some major issues, but also found ways to keep it light.

"It's a delight to be back in Indiana, especially since Indiana is now officially a blue state," Dean, the former governor of Vermont and Democratic National Chairman said.

Rove made sure to define the differences and similarities between he and Dean.

"He's on the far left and I'm on the common sense right," he remarked to a round of laughs.

"I do have respect for him -- and I hope he has respect for me -- as people who love our country," Rove added.

Surprisingly absent from the early portions of the debate was the issue of healthcare reform. Many of the issues discussed met with agreement on what the result should be, but disagreement over how to get there.

A couple of early questions centered on the nature of debate in Washington, in which the two sides can agree on little. Dean pointed to the two men's generation being more polarized, saying the generation of current students is different.

By Alex Turco/The DePauw-- Howard Dean
"We've spent a lot of time demonizing each other," Dean said.

Rove, on the other hand, said current political climate is not generational, but springs from the negative climate created in the 1990s between Bill Clinton and Newt Gingrich.

"We need a more healthy attitude and to have a respectful disagreement," Rove said.

On illegal immigration their opinions fell in line. Rove said the need is to secure our borders, institute a program for willing workers and resolve, in a humane way, the fact that people are here illegally.

"I agree," Dean said. "I thought George Bush showed a lot of courage with his immigration package.

"We have to stop beating up on immigrants in this country. We are immigrants, and it's what built this country," he continued.

Asked about a "crisis of confidence" in government, neither man showed much fear. Rove said the president shouldn't worry much about falling poll numbers right now.

"It comes and it goes. The question is, 'Is he doing the right thing?' More importantly, will we look back and say he was doing the right thing?" he said.

Dean pointed out how people show low approval for the institution of Congress, yet so often re-elect their own representatives and senators.

"I think I reject the notion that there's a crisis of confidence," he said.

As with most 800-pound gorillas, though, the health care debate did eventually rear its ugly head. And as expected, there was little agreement. Rove said he didn't want government bureaucracy intervention in health care. Dean, a medical doctor, saw it differently.

"The only bureaucrats I've ever had tell me what I could or couldn't do was an insurance company bureaucrat," he said.

Rove also pointed out that while the debate over healthcare may be tiresome, he's glad we are at a point in our country's history where that can be the hottest issue.

"I'm glad passions are running high about what our healthcare should be, rather than sex or race," he said.

Another issue central to the healthcare debate is that of the national deficit. While both men want to see the deficit come down, they disagree on how things got like they are and what can be done to fix it.

By Alex Turco/The DePauw-- Karl Rove
The Bush administration, according to Rove, worked hard to get spending down in spite of fighting two wars and an increased emphasis on security. He said the new health care plan would add billions to the deficit in the coming decade.

"We worked hard to ratchet down spending. Now (under Obama) it's going to blow back up," Rove said.

Dean showed confidence in the current administration and placed blame on Bush's tax cuts.

"I think we're going to get through this," he said. "We had to stimulate the economy."

Friday's event marked the third debate between the two men, but the first on a college campus. Stinebrickner said he was honored that the first took place at DePauw.

The debaters, likewise, remained aware of their surroundings and made sure to advise their young audience.

Rove encouraged the students to "remember families, communities and serving something greater than ourselves."

"We have a responsibility in everything we do, to serve,' he added.

Dean also exhorted the students to remain involved.

"You cannot take a vacation from politics," he said. "You have to be always involved with politics."

"Our generation had its shot at transforming the world, and we did, for better or worse," he added. "Now it's your turn, until your children elect their first president."

Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. If you feel that a comment is offensive, please Login or Create an account first, and then you will be able to flag a comment as objectionable. Please also note that those who post comments on bannergraphic.com may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.

I attended the debate last night. It was a good exchange. I thought the students at DPU and the other attendees were very polite and no big disturbances took place. There was much applause for both men and their ideas, which reflected the differences we, as Americans, have. I want to compliment DePauw on bringing these men here.

-- Posted by not gullible on Sat, Sep 12, 2009, at 9:20 AM

While on campus for the weekend to visit my son, I watched the debate and enjoyed it immensely.

I think Rove clearly won it on both style AND substance, although I must say I came away from it with more respect for Howard Dean than I expected. Maybe it's because the debate was held at an academic institution and not on MSNBC, but Dean was very constructive in supporting his positions, did not throw any mud, and in fact was actually quite respectful towards both Rove and his former boss, President Bush. Dean's defense of Obama was consistent, but I found it at times to be reluctant. I take from that the Democrats are very worried about the situation and how it bodes for 2010 and 2012.

Rove emerged as the far more principled person. He rebutted Dean's statist positions on a number of issues, and articulated common-sense alternatives that the mainstream media refuses to give airtime to. Rove was outstanding both in objection to Obama and in support of Libertarian principles.

Great job DePauw on bringing these two guys together on your beautiful campus.

-- Posted by DPU Dad on Sat, Sep 12, 2009, at 11:30 AM

Very good debate! As I DePauw student especially, I want to thank the University and the Ubbens for bringing our distinguished guests to campus last night.

-- Posted by aen2012 on Sat, Sep 12, 2009, at 4:14 PM

Sorry, but Rove lost me in the first five minutes with his description of finding a "mouse dropping" in President Casey's swimming pool. This after he surely had enjoyed a fine dinner at Casey's home with the very best that our city and university community have to offer in the way of hospitality, prepared by people making a LOT less than he did that evening. It's okay. The little people don't matter that much anyway to people like Rove. Yes, and I'm sure those same people won't mind waiting a bit longer for health care or miss that public option much either.

-- Posted by sneakers on Sun, Sep 13, 2009, at 7:54 AM

Rove has a very wry sense of humor, sneakers. There was nothing malicious in his remarks. I found him refreshing. Dean was OK, too, but not quite as entertaining as Rove.

-- Posted by not gullible on Sun, Sep 13, 2009, at 8:15 AM

Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: