Crabtree was the head football coach at North Central High School in Farmersburg since August 2005. In 2006, he was named the Southwest Seven Football Conference Co-Coach of the Year and the Indianapolis Colts Region Six Coach of the Week. He was named to the Wabash Valley All-Star Coaching Staff on four different occasions.
Crabtree's best record in his years at North Central was 8-3, and he ended his time at the high school at 24-38. After going 3-7 in his first year at the school in 2005, he took his team to back-to-back sectional finals and 8-3 season records. North Central then had two 1-9 seasons in a row before finishing last year at 3-7. The school's record in the years before hiring Crabtree, between 1970 and 2005, was 78-239.
Players and friends also made a Facebook page for the coach when rumors moved through the school corporation that Crabtree would be moving to another school in the corporation. The move was later shot down.
He is a licensed administrator and has an undergraduate degree in chemistry and physical education from Purdue University and a master's degree in chemistry and physical education from Ball State University.
Bagienski also applied for the last athletic director opening.