City decides not to purchase A-Way Home shelter building

Thursday, May 16, 2013
The City of Greencastle will not be purchasing the renovated former IGA store building that previously housed the A-Way Home Shelter and Housing Authority offices at 309 E. Franklin St. A proposal that would have seen the city purchase the site to facilitate its revival as a homeless shelter operated by the Beyond Homeless Inc. group has been deemed unfeasible by city officials.

Three months after it appeared the City of Greencastle might ride to the rescue of the local homeless shelter, that possibility has been deemed impractical by city officials.

After pondering the purchase of the former A-Way Home shelter property at 309 E. Franklin St. during an executive session earlier this month, the Greencastle City Council reluctantly went public with the bad news Tuesday night.

Councilman T.J. Smith was the first to address the issue, noting that his inital inclination was to favor the idea of the city buying the building and allowing the not-for-profit Beyond Homeless group to operate a new shelter and eventual buy the structure back.

However, after more introspection and more information came to light at the recent executive session, Smith said he changed his thinking.

"I don't think it's a good investment for the city to purchase the property," he explained Tuesday night.

Council President Adam Cohen agreed.

"At this point, I don't think we can purchase the building," Cohen said. "We're not in a position right now to run a shelter."

He suggested city officials would be receptive to putting up money to fund programs to help curb the homeless situation locally, but other local entities need to pay their fair share as well.

"Other people in this county had better start talking about this," Cohen said of the local homeless situation he punctuated with the statistic that 84 children in Greencastle schools this year listed themselves as homeless (that includes those living in homes of family members other than their parents).

Cohen surmised that equal numbers are likely in the county's other three school corporations.

He addressed the Putnam County township trustees by name in characterizing the problem as countywide.

"Trustees," Cohen said, "you say you need our help on the Humane shelter. You can't leave us hanging here on this. Every kid who is homeless tonight in Greencastle is a resident of Putnam County."

While the shelter group reportedly has a $7,000 commitment from Greencastle Township for 2013, the homeless shelter has never been backed by county funds. That will need to change to make the effort sustainable, city officials noted.

Councilman Smith, dressed in his county deputy uniform Tuesday night, agreed that homelessness is more than just a Greencastle concern.

"It's a county problem," Smith stressed.

Phyllis Rokicki seemed the most emotional in addressing the Council decision.

"My heart tells me one thing," she said, "while my head tells me something else."

Rokicki indicated, however, that the situation is not a lost cause.

"It doesn't mean we're never going to have a shelter in Greencastle," she said. "But the last thing we want to do as a city is to open the shelter and have to close it again."

Bill Wieland of the Beyond Homeless Inc. board said the group's initial reaction was disappointment that the city purchase won't happen.

"The reservations that were expressed here are all reasonable," Wieland said from the podium at City Hall. "We walk away feeling in no way rebuffed. We're together as far as heart is concerned."

Housing Authority Director Nicole Christ-lieb also said she understands the city's position but vowed, "you haven't seen the last of me."

"We're still trying to sell the building or put apartments in it," she said, adding her appreciation for "what the city has done and considered."

At its February meeting, the City Council had unanimously adopted Resolution 2013-4, declaring the city's intent to purchase the former A-Way Home property for the creation of a new homeless shelter.

The intention was for the Beyond Homeless organization to eventually become owners of the building. During the February discussion, Mayor Sue Murray even stressed that it was never the desire of the city to run a shelter.

"There is a need in the City of Greencastle to provide temporary housing for individuals and families that are homeless and need shelter," the resolution stated.

"The city has determined," the resolution went on to note, "that the location of the former homeless shelter is appropriate and available

However, in the long run, both initial investment and long-term financial considerations, as well as sustainability issues, combined to deem that plan impractical for the city to tackle alone.

The structure at the northwest corner of Locust and Franklin streets formerly housed the A-Way Home shelter, which opened in July 1996 and closed Sept. 10, 2011 after serving more than 2,500 homeless people over 15 years.

The community has gone without such a shelter since the September 2011 closing.

Comments
View 6 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • Why doesn't DePauw get interested in this project?? I think it would be a good match for them. Plenty of professors and students would be interested in helping.

    -- Posted by donantonioelsabio on Thu, May 16, 2013, at 11:26 AM
  • This is disappointing on all levels. If the article is an accurate summary of the meeting and reasons not to move forward, the problem appears to be a "City vs. County" feud. If the statistics are accurate, they clearly prove the need to address a growing homelessness issue. Both the City and County should be ashamed.

    We are an awarding winning "Green" Community, and now a "Stellar Community" where grant funding documents housing as a "Goal". The grant also notes "wellness initiatives such as walking trails". Would homelessness become a concern if a "tent city" developed along one of our very fine walking trails underneath a canopy of "sustainable and green" deciduous groves?

    -- Posted by Seagullslim on Thu, May 16, 2013, at 1:21 PM
  • The Putnam County Trustees have 10's of 000's of dollars in their bloated budgets going unused each year. Could sum of their funds be used as well as some county funds?

    -- Posted by Lookout on Thu, May 16, 2013, at 1:46 PM
  • How's that new multi-million dollar parking garage coming along?

    -- Posted by jetmx96 on Thu, May 16, 2013, at 8:17 PM
  • I guess that having 84 children homeless is not enough for change to happen. As far as the new parking garage goes--it will provide needed shelter for those who need temporary housing. Welcome to the Progressive Greencastle.

    -- Posted by donantonioelsabio on Thu, May 16, 2013, at 11:45 PM
  • I THINK THIS IS A BIG MISTAKE FOR THE CITY NOT TO PURCHASE THIS BUILDING. IT'S IN GOOD CONDITION AND HAS A GOOD LOCATION. IT SEEMS TO ME IT WOULD BE BETTER FINANCING THIS THAN TO BUILD A HUGE PARKING GARAGE FOR DOWNTOWN GREENCASTLE WHEN THERE ARE HARDLY ANY STORES TO SHOP AT. BOTH SPENCER AND BRAZIL HAVE A YMCA.....COULD THE OLD A=WAY HOME BUILDING BE USED FOR SOMETHING LIKE THAT. IT WOULD GIVE OUR YOUNG COMMUNITY RESIDENTS A DECENT PLACE TO SPEND TIME......

    -- Posted by lhmh on Fri, May 17, 2013, at 1:25 AM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: