NP board passes COVID changes in divided vote

Monday, November 22, 2021

ROACHDALE — The North Putnam School Board’s regular meeting Thursday evening was accented by contentions over the school corporation’s COVID guidelines as they stood.

One member of the audience threw an expletive before obliging to leave. Another claimed that COVID was not harmful to children and that masks were ineffective. Echoing a sentiment that they were too stringent, another said the guidelines were “asinine” and a “power trip.”

The guidelines at issue were implemented at North Putnam late last August, in which COVID positivity rates in individual schools and corporation-wide became the overarching factor for masking and closures. School leaders then advocated that this was aimed at mitigating a spread of the virus.

As a proposal by Board Vice President Mark Hoke, the board approved to amend these thresholds effective immediately at the meeting. Hoke was joined in the affirmative vote by Rachel Mandeville, Eric Oliver and Amber Greene.

However, it was divided with opposing votes from Board President Travis Lambermont and members Joanie Knapp and Ron Spencer.

Masking will now be required if a school building’s positivity rate reaches eight percent of its student population. Masking would then remain in place until the rates falls below five percent. It is still required on school buses per a federal mandate.

Corporation-wide masking as such was eliminated from the guidelines. Previously, it was required if the corporation’s positivity rate was at one percent of the total population.

School buildings will close for five days if the positivity rate is at 10 percent or more, where it was originally set at three percent. A closure would also occur if a school’s quarantine rate reaches 25 percent, a change from 20 percent. The rate would then be re-evaluated after the five days.

Based on the student populations when the original guidelines were put in place, the exceeding threshold for closing individual schools means the following:

• North Putnam High School (444 students): 44 positive cases, up from 14;

• North Putnam Middle School (336): 34 positive cases, up from 11;

• Roachdale Elementary School (213): 21 positive cases, up from seven;

• Bainbridge Elementary School (376): 38 positive cases, up from 12

Meanwhile, exceeding the threshold for masking in individual school buildings means the following:

• North Putnam High School: 36 positive cases, with five percent being 22;

• North Putnam Middle School: 27 positive cases, with five percent being 17;

• Roachdale Elementary School: 17 positive cases; with five percent being 11;

• Bainbridge Elementary School: 30 positive cases, with five percent being 19

Despite changing the positivity rates, the sticking point brought up by those in the audience was contact tracing. Board member Eric Oliver provided that it was detrimental to parents who have to take off work to maybe look after multiple children.

Hoke provided that automatically quarantining students who may be healthy or otherwise symptomatic was not needed. There was no “magic dart,” he said, but that students have to be in school as well as monitored by parents. As such, they should communicate with the corporation’s health clinic.

“I’m all about choice, and I also believe there’s nobody who should be condemned for wearing a mask,” Spencer said. “Nobody is more responsible for your children than the parents.”

Spencer said the changes were an opportunity to loosen up masking and closures at North Putnam. Though he provided that “some sort” of contact tracing needed to be in place, he put the onus for students being healthy on parents.

“This whole thing is very upsetting,” Lambermont said. In a different turn, he cast his frustrations at the state not setting guidelines for local health departments which school boards could then follow. This, he provided, is why the board has had to make policies for North Putnam.

Board Secretary Rachel Mandeville also supported the new guidelines in terms of loosening up the policy in general. As to masks, she also provided an analogy to football helmets: Just as they cannot totally prevent concussions, masking is not “fool-proof.” Nonetheless, they are one layer of protection.

“I’m ready to worry about their mental health more than their physical health,” Greene said for her part. Though she supported the new thresholds, Greene noted that she was against the original guidelines.

As to her opposing the motion, Knapp said she wanted to see a more gradual step-down in the guidelines.

Superintendent Nicole Allee told the Banner Graphic Monday afternoon that North Putnam’s COVID dashboard would not be updated until next week due to the Thanksgiving holiday.

View 9 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • The SCL congregants are going to be beside themselves

    -- Posted by beg on Mon, Nov 22, 2021, at 11:58 PM
  • If you disagree with your school board’s policies, then both showing up for the meetings and voting are critical. Remember the names of those who don’t represent your views, and vote accordingly at election time.

    -- Posted by techphcy on Tue, Nov 23, 2021, at 8:33 AM
  • *

    Beg - Looks like a slow day fishing for you. Maybe things will pick up for you. Patience is a virtue. Hang tough!!

    -- Posted by RSOTS on Tue, Nov 23, 2021, at 9:13 AM
  • Cases! Cases! Cases!

    The PCR tests are highly inaccurate at detecting covid-19, 97% false positives. (they really don't know how bad they are)

    CDC is recommending discontinued use by January '22

    -- Posted by direstraits on Wed, Nov 24, 2021, at 10:06 AM
  • Direstraits, we have been over this before. Your statements above are completely inaccurate. But if you wish to keep believing the lies being fed to you, that is your prerogative.

    -- Posted by Koios on Wed, Nov 24, 2021, at 10:15 AM
  • PCR tests don't mean a thing.

    They are very limited because they were adapted unsuccessfully from influenza tests. Even the alphabet agencies say they're a problem.

    How do you make decisions on tests that don't isolate whatever variant you might (or might not) have?

    They register a positive on a common cold, or flu variant , or the Wuhan.

    Are they all same when deciding policy?

    No. Basic stuff.

    Next time you get a PCR ask them what cycle threshold did they use to determine positivity.

    In the beginning of this fiasco they were cycling up to 50 times to get the positive response needed, the cases number exploded. (Ten cycles are the outside number that should be used)

    Panic ensued and the little Napoleon bureaucrat doctor (not a doctor that sees patients) was off to races and the BIG CASH-IN.

    Obviously this is over the head of the basement dwellers, watching "The View" daily.

    Everyone else gets it, if you take off those panic hats.

    -- Posted by direstraits on Wed, Nov 24, 2021, at 8:24 PM
  • “ CDC is recommending discontinued use by January '22”.

    From the CDC NOTICE you posted a while ago, it does state that the CDC is discontinuing the current RT-PCR test. That part is true. If you keep reading that notice you would note that they are replacing it with a new RT-PCR test that can simultaneously detect both RNA from the virus that causes Covid and the virus that causes the flu. One swab, one test, that detects both viruses. This makes diagnosis of any underlying virus more efficient and more convenient. This is the whole story, not the partial story that fits your agenda.

    -- Posted by Koios on Wed, Nov 24, 2021, at 9:00 PM
  • Should sport participants wear masks since they are so close together and probably having contact?

    -- Posted by beg on Sat, Nov 27, 2021, at 1:41 AM
  • I understand the silence. So playbook!

    -- Posted by beg on Sun, Nov 28, 2021, at 11:49 PM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: