Bon Ton restaurant remains open, celebrates 73 years Saturday

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

BAINBRIDGE -- Joe Hess got an extra Christmas present this year. He appeared before the Bainbridge Town Council in mid-December hoping someone would come up with a plan to save the restaurant his father opened in 1936.

He got his wish. The Bon Ton Restaurant will celebrate its 73rd birthday on Saturday, Jan. 24 with cake and the Bon Ton Deluxe special -- a double bacon cheeseburger with special sauce.

Bon Ton Restaurant owners Sue and Mark Blake are counting on support from the community in keeping the 73 year-old business open. The restaurant nearly closed after being on the auction block in December. An outcry from local residents encouraged the Blake's to undertake operating the restaurant.

New restaurant owners and Putnam County residents Mark and Sue Blake took over running the restaurant after it went on the auction block last December.

The Blakes' relatives purchased the Bon Ton but knew they didn't want to run a restaurant. They offered it to Mark and Sue, who had both worked in restaurant management and wanted to get back to it.

Mark managed Ponderosa restaurants as well as the Greencastle and Cloverdale McDonald's and a couple in Terre Haute. Sue had trained waitresses for various restaurants as well.

"Now was a good time for us to take over the restaurant. Our four kids are grown and three live out of state. We were ready to try it," said Sue.

The couple both work fulltime jobs outside of running the Bon Ton, but hope to eventually work only in their restaurant.

"We have a great staff. They are behind us 100 percent. They keep things running all week and Mark and I are there on the weekends," said Sue.

Their son Michael has begun working at the restaurant, following in his parents' footsteps.

"He wants to start learning restaurant management and this is a good way to start," said Sue.

And, even though their three daughters Whitney and Lindsey Briones and Tabitha Lucas all live out of state, they are offering ideas, suggestions and support to their parents. Lindsey is even designing new menus.

Besides the Blakes, the restaurant employs six staff members who are all local residents. Raye Hites, Phyllis Harmless, Mindy Robbin, Nellie Conrad, Moleigh Reed and Melissa Yeagley have all worked for the Bon Ton and plan to stay on with the new owners.

The Bon Ton has it share of regular customers like Joe Blaikie, Mike Clifford and Stewart Russell. The men sit at a community table in the center of the restaurant.

Russell was celebrating his 70th birthday. He generally eats both breakfast and lunch at the Bon Ton.

"The chair at the end of the table is his," said Sue. "Occasionally someone else sits there but most of us know that is his spot," she laughed.

Currently, the restaurant is open Saturday-Thursday from 6 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. and on Fridays from 6 a.m. to 8 p.m.

They have lengthened their Sunday hours so people have a place to come after church. A new fried chicken special has been added to the Sunday menu in hopes of enticing more folks in the doors.

"Hopefully, in a couple of months we can extend the restaurant hours," said Sue.

Homemade pies are one of their specialties. They also offer homemade meals of fried chicken on Sundays and fried catfish on Friday nights. They have a breakfast menu that includes everyone's favorite morning foods with items like biscuits and gravy, eggs and bacon, sausage and hotcakes.

Their lunch menu has meatloaf and beef manhattans and all the standard sandwiches. Some people say the star of the Bon Ton is their Bon Ton Deluxe Special. Others insist it is the delicious baked fresh everyday homemade pies. They even offer sugar free pies.

Joe Blaikie, Mike Clifford and Stewart Russell sit at the community table in the Bon Ton Restaurant. The three are regular customers. Russell was celebrating his 70th birthday at the restaurant that will turn 73 next Saturday.

The Bon Ton had been for sale for several years and eventually was auctioned off. However, there was no interruption of service in the restaurant when it was sold.

Gene Hess opened the Bon Ton in January 1936. At that time, Bainbridge had a lot of traffic running through the town on U.S. 36.

In 1945, Hess sold his business to a man who worked for him. The trolley car burned in 1947.

Hess, who was then in the construction business, built the building where the Bon Ton now stands, and the restaurant was back in business.

When it appeared that the Bon Ton was closing, there was an outcry among Bainbridge residents to keep the restaurant open.

"I hope everyone will support us. Start by coming out next Saturday for our 73rd birthday celebration," said Sue.

In the meantime, regulars like Stewart Russell will continue to come not just for the good food but also for the community and friendship offered by the little restaurant.

As the enticing odor of blackberry, sugar cream and coconut cream pie wafted out of the kitchen, Stewart said his goodbyes for the morning.

"I'll be back in a little while for lunch," he said.

"We'll have a birthday pie waiting for you," Sue smiled back.

The Bon Ton is located at 110 W. Pat Rady Way (U.S. 36), Bainbridge. They can be reached at 765-522-3221.

View 6 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • Congratulations to Mark and Sue Blake on the 73rd birthday of the BonTon Restaurant. Hope the birthday celebration is a huge success and hope 2009 will be a wonderful year for the historical little restaurant. Can't wait to try the Bon Ton Deluxe Special and one of the home-made pies!

    -- Posted by greatstuff on Tue, Jan 20, 2009, at 9:03 AM
  • They can't please everyone but it sounds like you haven't been there for awhile. I sure am seeing lots of cars in the parking lot these days. There are also plenty of older folks can't get out of town that often either.

    -- Posted by bannerstuff on Tue, Jan 20, 2009, at 11:48 AM
  • Support local independent business!! I hope they succeed. The service industry is a rough one. Pondarosa? Where everything is processed and packaged, dilivered then thrown on a grill or in a warmer? That's the mentality that awarded us Wal Mart and the exact mentality that makes it so hard for small business. Shop local, eat local. Be proud of these people for wanting to give a small community somewhere to eat without driving 15 miles.

    -- Posted by townielove on Tue, Jan 20, 2009, at 2:07 PM
  • I am so proud of the new owners of the Bon Ton Restaurant in Bainbridge, Mark and Sue Blake for taking on such a large responsibility. This may become the greatest learning and growing adventure of their life. Anyone that has run or currently running or operating a business understands the stress, responsibility and the hours that come with ownership. I pray that these folks will be successful and that they go out and help others to be successful. I ask God to guide their decisions both personal and in business.

    -- Posted by davidbblake on Tue, Jan 20, 2009, at 2:35 PM
  • I can't wait to try it out! Congratulations to the new owners.

    p.s. townielove......even the local places have food delivered and "thrown on a grill or warmer." Thats how restaurants operate. They're called "vendors."

    -- Posted by fashionista on Tue, Jan 20, 2009, at 3:02 PM
  • More good news to celebrate in Putnam County.Good Luck , we will spread the word and patronize this restaurant!!Homemadee pies???, Were there !

    -- Posted by skittlebug on Wed, Jan 21, 2009, at 9:09 AM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: