Hargrove convicted

Thursday, January 20, 2011

GREENCASTLE -- A Greencastle man who shot an assault rifle at a Putnam County Sheriff's Department Reserve deputy was convicted by a jury Thursday of Class A felony attempted murder and Class D felonies criminal recklessness with a deadly weapon and resisting law enforcement.

Justin Hargrove, 25, will be sentenced on Feb. 17. He could be sentenced to up to 56 years in prison.

"It was a just verdict," said Putnam County Prosecutor Tim Bookwalter said. "Shooting at a police officer is not acceptable."

Hargrove was charged after an April 6 incident in which he was one of five individuals that drove around Greencastle shooting out of the windows of a moving vehicle driven by Hargrove's then-girlfriend, Lacey Couch.

The five guns used in the incident were stolen during an April 4 burglary at a Coatesville residence. Two of Hargrove's co-defendants, Michael Scott Pryor and Keven Dale Crowe, were convicted in that burglary.

The shooting spree led to a high-speed chase, and eventually a foot pursuit of Hargrove, who jumped from the vehicle while it was moving.

During the vehicle pursuit, Hargrove fired an AR-15 assault rifle at Putnam County Sheriff's Department Reserve Officer Matthew Biggs as Biggs sat in his police cruiser and was preparing to stop the vehicle in which Hargrove was riding.

Hargrove took the stand Thursday -- he was the only witness to testify for the defense.

Hargrove told the jury he had grown up in Indianapolis, but had moved to Greencastle a little over a year ago. He said he had a 10th grade education and he had never had long-term employment.

At the time of his arrest, he said, he was living with Couch.

Couch, Crowe and Pryor all testified for the state.

Hargrove said Crowe and Pryor were "friends of mine." He said they had met through a mutual friend and had spent much time together, playing cards and video games and watching television.

Hargrove went as far as to say that he had considered Crowe and Pryor his best friends in Greencastle.

Hargrove said the night of the shooting he had met up with Crowe and Pryor, and that they had planned to "just hang out" as far as he knew. He said Crowe and Pryor did show him the firearms, and that he had handled and eventually shot them, but that he had no idea they were stolen.

"They said they got them from a friend," Hargrove said.

Hargrove said he and his friends took the guns to a secluded area to shoot them, and that he didn't think what they were doing was dangerous.

As the group left the spot where they were shooting and became aware that they were being followed by a police car, Hargrove said, Couch "tripped out." Hargrove said Couch had been drinking, smoking marijuana and taking Xanax (for which she had a prescription). He said the rest of the people in the car had also been drinking, and that Couch had been sharing her Xanax with them.

"She thought she was going to jail," Hargrove said.

When asked about shooting at Biggs, Hargrove said he was just trying to scare the officer -- and that if he had wanted to kill him, he would have.

"Did you ever have any intention of shooting anyone?" Hargrove's attorney Sidney Tongret asked Hargrove.

"No," Hargrove said.

"Have you ever shot anyone?" Tongret asked.

"No," Hargrove responded.

Hargrove said he just wanted Biggs to stop following him and his friends.

"He was following us and he was coming fast," Hargrove said.

Hargrove said he was high when he shot in Biggs' direction, and that he only fired one round.

Hargrove said the reason he decided to jump from the car was to make the police come after him so his friends could get away.

"You weren't trying to protect anyone but yourself," Bookwalter said. "You went back to Lacey's house, which sent the police there. She ended up arrested and she lost her child. Worked out real good for Lacey, didn't it?"

Bookwalter also took exception to Hargrove's statement that everyone in the car was doing something illegal except for him. Bookwalter asked Hargrove if he was "drinking," "smoking weed" and "popping pills," and Hargrove said he had been.

Tongret pointed out that, once police found Hargrove, Hargrove "didn't fight, struggle or run."

The fact that Hargrove at first denied any involvement in the shootings, Tongret said, was because Hargrove was scared.

"What did you think would happen if you confessed?" Tongret asked.

"I'd go to prison," Hargrove said.

In his taped interview, Hargrove acted genuinely shocked when he was told he was being charged with attempted murder, exclaiming "Are you serious?"

"Did you think you had tried to murder anyone?" Tongret asked.

"No," Hargrove said.

View 7 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • Tongret tried to portray this guy as a victim of circumstance...But if you ask around in Northern Putnam County you'll find that he had been starting fights with high schoolers and was generally a trouble maker.

    In my opinion, a just conviction. Now let's see how easy he gets off on his sentence...I'm guessing he'll get 20 years and be out in 10 if he behaves...That's 10 years of free food, water and shelter. He'll play a lot of cards and meet a lot of "great" people.

    Then, after a prison education, he'll be back out on the streets, no more fit for society then he is now. Our prison system is broken, fellow Americans. It's sad that a portion of my tax dollar goes to support trash like this.

    Anyway, thank God that officer Biggs didn't die that night. Purposely shooting the hood of a moving vehicle, while you're shooting from a moving vehicle would be very, very impressive.

    -- Posted by chaas013 on Fri, Jan 21, 2011, at 6:20 AM
  • OK, let's hear from the few local idiots about how Greencastle is soooooo "racist" for this conviction of attempted murder ... If you do not like this county; LEAVE. Maybe you can move to Greene County or Monroe County -- you know, places that are racism-free. ... I'm waiting....

    Thanks to the jury for the verdict.

    -- Posted by GRNT on Fri, Jan 21, 2011, at 7:22 AM
  • Well that Officer was following them awful close and going really fast. They were probably scared he was out to "get" them. Maybe they thought they were being "profiled". :)

    -- Posted by exhoosier2 on Fri, Jan 21, 2011, at 7:48 AM
  • Hey GRNT---I believe by your comment that you are the racist!

    -- Posted by interested party on Fri, Jan 21, 2011, at 9:06 AM
  • glad this person got convicted of this crime, great job jury, now lets hope me gets the max sentance. im not racist im proud of my heritage!

    -- Posted by lleonard47 on Fri, Jan 21, 2011, at 9:24 AM
  • If you go back a few years to a certain person who shot and killed another person over their love triangle with his wife. He was out in three? Crazy I think.

    -- Posted by Bentoverabarrel on Sun, Jan 23, 2011, at 2:07 PM
  • "If you go back a few years to a certain person who shot and killed another person over their love triangle with his wife. He was out in three? Crazy I think."


    That's what a high paid attorney from Indianapolis can do for you.

    -- Posted by ProblemTransmission on Thu, Jan 27, 2011, at 2:29 PM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: