Unemployment stats belie local jobs picture

Tuesday, October 28, 2014
The marquee at the Greencastle McDonald's is one of several local sites proclaiming employment opportunities available in the Putnam County area. (Photo by ERIC BERNSEE)

Straddling the narrow concrete median that divides those entering the Greencastle Walmart from the spendthrifts exiting onto Indianapolis Road, a thirtysomething man in jeans and sweatshirt cradles a cellphone between his neck and shoulder while holding up a crudely created cardboard sign scrawled with a brief message of despair.

Not the traditional "Will work for food" plea, mind you, but simply "Family in need of help."

Three exiting cars slow as drivers press dollar bills into his palm while he pays little attention to them, offering just a nod in return as he chats away on his phone.

Ironically, 100 yards to his right a large roadside sign at Ascena Group details job opportunities currently available, while on the opposite side of the street, Chiyoda proclaims in big letters, "Now hiring."

Meanwhile, drive up to McDonald's, a half-mile to the west, and its marquee notes, "Now hiring smiling faces for any shift."

So therein lies the dichotomy that has become the Putnam County jobs scene.

"You're not the first person who has pointed that out today," Greencastle/Putnam County Development Center Director Bill Dory says in response to the situation being brought up during discussions at the recent Greencastle Redevelopment Commission meeting.

While the current local jobless rate of 5.2 percent is just a tick behind the state average of 5.1 percent for September, the county ranking is tied with Benton and Scott counties for 55th best among Indiana's 92 counties.

Surprisingly, at the same time, several local businesses are advertising their openings, practically begging for help. All that while the number of people employed locally is at its second highest level ever, Dory said.

Moments earlier, Dory had just told the Redevelopment Commission "there are lots of job opportunities in the community for people who want to work."

The economic development expert had met with a couple of local employers that morning, coming away with a similar message to those spelled out in signage on the city's East Side.

"They're looking for people," he said. "There are jobs available if people are so inclined."

Putnam County reached its highest historic annual average of 17,793 people participating in the labor force in 2005, Dory explained, while in 2006, the county reached its highest historic annual average of 16,797 persons employed.

"In the last few months," he told the Banner Graphic, "the monthly

numbers are close to these historic highs with 17,918 people participating in the labor force in July of 2014 and 16,854 people employed in July of 2014.

"While September's employment and unemployment numbers are slightly lower," Dory noted, "it is not unusual for the monthly numbers to move up and down each month."

September's report showed 17,483 persons in the local labor force, and 16,576 persons employed. Those numbers are less than two percent below the historic highs.

Yet the county's jobless rate is higher than the state average.

That unemployment rate, Dory explained, is the result, in part, of people entering or re-entering the labor force slightly faster than the growth in employment.

"Given the number of businesses seeking new employees both here in Putnam County and in neighboring Hendricks County, this is not a bad thing," Dory suggested.

Overall, the economy across the state continues to improve, he added.

"Here in Indiana," Dory said, "many of the low unemployment counties (i.e., Hamilton, Boone and Hendricks) are around the largest cities such as Indianapolis. Often these areas see recovery first, which then spreads to more rural areas such as Putnam County.

"The monthly employment, unemployment and unemployment rate for Putnam County is the local version of the numbers reported for the nation in local and national media," he added. "In full disclosure, the margin of error in the local numbers is larger than the state and national numbers."

While the Putnam County figure for September ranks 55th best in the state, that is still better than three contiguous counties -- Clay at 5.9 percent, good for 12th worst; Parke at 5.6 percent for 71st best (or 22nd worst); and Owen at 5.5, tied for 63rd best.

Meanwhile, neighboring counties Hendricks, Morgan and Montgomery all landed in the upper half of the September numbers with Hendricks uncharacteristically out of the top 10 and tied for 11th best at 4.2 percent. Morgan was at 4.5 percent, good for 24th best, while Montgomery came in at 4.9 percent, tied for 44th.

Indiana's best jobless figure (3.4 percent) is again owned by Dubois County with Hamilton and Bartholomew tied for second at 3.8, followed in the top five by Wells and Daviess at 3.9.

Rounding out the Hoosier top 10 for September are Kosciusko and Boone at 4.0, followed by Pulaski, Martin and Jackson, all at 4.1 percent.

Meanwhile, landing at the bottom of Indiana jobless pack for September were Lake at 7.2 percent unemployment, Sullivan at 7.1 percent, Fayette and Vigo at 7.0 percent, followed by LaPorte at 6.5 percent, Vermillion at 6.4, Lawrence at 6.2, and Grant, Greene, Jasper and Miami, all at 6.0.

View 6 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • Most of these people standing with signs on the corner, make $100-$300 dollars a day tax free. Why would they want to work for their money like rest of us? Sorry, but I will not enable their lifestyle.

    -- Posted by cmgrove on Wed, Oct 29, 2014, at 6:59 AM
  • Most of if not all those standing near Wal MArt are not PUtnam Co. residents. Help locals not those please. They make lots of money each day by standing and begging here in our community.

    -- Posted by momma-j on Wed, Oct 29, 2014, at 8:03 AM
  • Panhandling should not be allowed. Can't the City or County put a stop to this? There are jobs to be had, go out and work for a living like the rest of us!!

    -- Posted by Rainbow6 on Wed, Oct 29, 2014, at 9:29 AM
  • That's part of what is wrong with this country,people standing around with their HANDS OUT,INSTEAD OF ROLLING UP THEIR SLEEVES AND GOING TO WORK! I see these people BEGGING for hand outs being bussed in to our county from a 15 passinger van with indy plates everyday!I've stopped and offered them honest work for fair pay and was told "No Thanks",don't give these BUMS a DIME!

    -- Posted by obeone on Wed, Oct 29, 2014, at 10:54 AM
  • Has money for a cell phone? Will work for food? Enuff said.

    -- Posted by Ishowalot on Wed, Oct 29, 2014, at 9:01 PM
  • I don't know this man's situation, but here's what I think about panhandlers ..

    1. $100-$300/day non-taxed vs $7/hour taxed?

    2. It's easier (these days) and less humiliating (these days) to beg for help on the corner.

    3. Maybe if panhandlers were required to CLAIM their income, there would be less of them?

    4. I don't know how the city would be able to account for the money they earn.

    5. Jobs to be had to those who WANT to work. That's an oxymoron for many these days.

    I will gladly buy a sandwich, water, a jacket, shoes .. before I will give ANYONE money. I will buy groceries, pay a water bill, but money will not exchange hands.

    That is my recommendation to others.

    -- Posted by Emmes on Thu, Oct 30, 2014, at 10:54 AM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: