Local educators urge legislators to do something about state testing issue

Thursday, December 10, 2015

At an educational forum fittingly sponsored by Farm Bureau, it was the four Putnam County school superintendents who planted the seeds of change and provided food for thought.

With State Rep. Jim Baird (R-Greencastle) and State Sen. Pete Miller (R-Avon) serving as panelists during a luncheon gathering at Area 30 Career Center, the county superintendents and others expressed frustration at how Indiana's test scores have been miscalculated, misguided and misleading.

Making a point about school grades and testing inequities, South Putnam Superintendent Bruce Bernhardt (left) addresses his comments to local legislators as retired former North Putnam and Eminence Supt. Murray Pride listens.

And all that has cultivated a scenario described by Greencastle Superintendent Dawn Puckett as a "spiraling out-of -control situation for education."

The fact that scores produced from statewide tests like the End of Course Assessment (ECA) and ISTEP are factored into annual letter grades each school receives as well as tied to compensation for teachers is just unfair and unnecessary, the school officials stressed.

It's not a situation that has developed overnight, the educators said, explaining a series of actions have undermined staff morale and wreaked havoc on school budgets.

Some of the factors that have spawned the education issue include:

-- Performance tied to teacher compensation packages.

-- New tests with new vendors, resulting in old vendors not cooperating with schools or the state.

-- Changes in standards.

-- Changes in the Complexity Index formula -- tied to the local poverty rate -- that have negatively impacted local schools.

The result of the latter, Supt. Puckett told the legislators, is that "the haves have more and the have-nots have less."

The situation has adversely affected the teaching environment as well, she said.

"My teachers are hugely stressed. I've been losing teachers in the middle of the school year the last two or three years.

"All of it combined has become cataclysmic," Puckett added.

Cloverdale's Greg Linton agreed.

"The frustration just flows over the top," he said. "Just give us some time to respond. There hasn't been a break to allow us to catch our breath and catch up."

North Putnam Superintendent Dan Noel added an amen to that.

"We've got a lot of upset parents, a lot of upset teachers," he said. "There's a lot of fingerpointing going on. And I'll be honest, most of it is being directed at the state.

"I think this has really done an injustice to our state," Noel added. "It has done an injustice to our families and it has done an injustice to our schools. We've made our state look terrible to the nation with what we've done."

Perhaps worse than that, Noel suggested, is that educators "don't think we're being heard."

That's why they were busy bending the ears of Rep. Baird and Sen. Miller, challenging them to do something about the inequities of the system.

For instance, in one example cited, a school that had an "A" grade after prior testing dropped to an "F" school under the latest testing because the results of 50 tested students were somehow missing and thus evaluated as zeroes by the test results.

"You've heard us say today," Supt. Noel said, "that we don't think the testing is equitable. Do you think January is the time to do something?"

That is when the Indiana General Assembly reconvenes but legislators appear intent on pushing the education issue to the 2017 session.

The educators called for a moratorium on the release of any test scores or school grades until the situation can be straightened out.

But while Indiana Gov. Mike Pence has said the state won't punish teachers for low test scores, he's also said he's opposed to waiving the A-F grades for schools.

The message the county superintendents tried to plow through was that the legislators don't need to wait until 2017 and have the power to make changes during the 2016 legislative session.

"I'm just as concerned as you about these young kids sitting there while we try and hash this out," Rep. Baird said.

Sen. Miller, meanwhile, reminded the group that the state is in "year one of a four- or five-year transition."

Miller, who served on the Education Committee that met five times this summer, said the panel talked generally about the issue and about "eliminating the high-stakes nature we've placed on these tests."

"I don't think we need to test kids for 13 hours to tell whether a kid is doing well or not. Your teachers don't need a test to know who's performing and who's not. It's the same with teachers. Principals know who's performing and who needs help."

The senator said he wanted to "push back a bit" on the notion the testing issue has cast the state in a bad light.

"The fact the scores are lower was expected," he said due to test changes. "I would rather a student and parent know if a kid's not passing grade level."

He also stressed that the Legislature is charged with implementation, not policy.

"I'm owning up to you today," Miller said, "that I think there's an error in policy."

Assigning A to F grades, retired former North Putnam and Eminence Superintendent Murray Pride said, "has become a status symbol as far as schools go." He said the program was never supposed to be a comparative effort pitting this school vs. that school, but that's the public perception.

"Now we're all looking at the newspapers and seeing we're an A school and you're an F school."

South Putnam Superintendent Bruce Bernhardt readily agreed.

"It's a disservice to put out these letter grades to the public. We can't make them understand as a community. All they see is the letter grade. All they see is The Banner puts in I got a D and you got a B."

Bernhardt urged a further moratorium on making school letter grades public "until we can get it right."

Also, assigning schools grades can affect enrollment, Pride said, which in turn affects school funding as some students transfer out of lower-grade schools for another A or B school nearby.

And the results can even negatively impact the economy, Cloverdale Supt. Linton said.

"Businesses and companies will look at Indiana, and if they see declining scores, they won't want to bring their companies and their businesses here.

"Schools aren't really failing," he stressed, "education is better than it's ever been."

It just doesn't look that way, Linton suggested, because of the win-or-lose nature of test scores and school grades.

Following an education forum Tuesday at the Area 30 Career Center, North Putnam Supt. Dan Noel (left) gives District 44 State Rep. Jim Baird (R-Greencastle) a pat on the back.

So can anything be done in January?

"January's just going to be a one-year reprieve," Sen. Miller said, alluding to the status of test scores, not school grades.

"I think these discussions need to take place outside the General Assembly," he added. "Our vehicle for discussion there is a bill."

That seemed to frustrate Noel even more.

"If the system is flawed and it's not right, I don't understand how you, as our representatives, can't do something about it," the North Putnam superintendent said.

Rep. Baird seemed to take offense to the notion legislators aren't listening to the educators.

"I have never not listened to you folks," he said, adding that he takes improved graduation rates and better English and algebra scores as positives.

"The bottom line for me," the Greencastle lawmaker said, "is we've got to have young people who are talented."

Noel continued the challenge.

"We need help to straighten this mess up," he said. "There has to be some way coming up in January to straighten this mess out because right now it's going down the toilet ... that's just the best way I can put it.

"This is flawed, stop it. You have the power, you have that authority."

Baird looked to the superintendents for guidance.

"What's the solution?" he asked. "What's the answer?"

The challenge, Miller said, is that the state is not just going to end all testing and with it, educational accountability.

"But what are we going to do?" the state senator asked.

For one thing, Cloverdale's Linton said, "it would be nice to find a way to improve the tone (of the ongoing argument) so it's not so adversarial."

They all agreed on that.

"I've given my time here today," Rep. Baird said, "not for you to hear from me but for me to hear from you."

And hear from them, the legislators did.

* * *

At the conclusion of the program, Putnam County Farm Bureau President Steve Cash announced the 2016 local Legislative Update sessions are set for the third Saturday of January, February and possibly March.

That means the 8 a.m. sessions at the Farm Bureau Insurance Office on North Jackson Street in Greencastle will be on Jan. 16, Feb. 20 and possibly March 19.

View 1 comment
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • Nice job to the area superintendents and Murray Pride. You are faced with the task of trying to run your schools with some of the craziest rules ever in the history of public education. We have an educator at the helm of the Indiana Department of Education. But due to her being a member of the opposition party, her hands have been tied and in some cases cut off by those who claim to know better and have no idea what education is all about. I thought former Governor Daniels took the life out of public education. But I believe that our current governor and current legislature have just about killed it. No one knows what our four local school leaders deal with daily. They should all be given "Purple Hearts" for dealing with all the wounds passed down to them.

    Thanks to the two gentlemen who were at least willing to come and listen, but to say you can't do anything until 2017? Oh Please! Just turn it back over to educators and the job will get done. And get done satisfactorily!

    Schools ..... hang in there and keep up the great work. I hate to think where we would be without you now

    -- Posted by cvilleguy on Thu, Dec 10, 2015, at 10:35 PM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: