Rokita visits South Putnam students

Thursday, March 10, 2016
Congressman Todd Rokita (right) visits the South Putnam Aquaculture room Wednesday with Principal Mike Schimpf. (Banner Graphic/CHELSEA MODGLIN)

During a visit to South Putnam High School Wednesday afternoon, SPHS seniors gave Congressman Todd Rokita mixed reviews as he delivered a speech and answered their questions.

Students' comments after the speech consisted of "I feel he skirted around the questions that everybody had. He tried to get it back to what he believed in" and "I'm upset that he changed my question from a civil rights issue to a budget issue." Before delivering his speech, Congressman Rokita toured the school while talking to Principal Mike Schmipf about school safety and his latest bill, the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), which President Obama recently signed into law. The measure permits the state to determine when, how and how long to test student performance, and effectively scraps the No Child Left Behind Act.

"This one-size-fits-all doesn't work," Congressman Rokita said. "We have returned education where it belongs under the Constitution."

Education was again a topic during the question-and-answer portion of his speech, but first Congressman Rokita opened his remarks with, "I came here to serve you, the newest adults in our society."

He went on to explain the national debt and federal budget to the students, saying the portion he can actually vote on is the discretionary spending constituting just a third of the budget. The other two-thirds of the budget is protected by entitlement law.

"Right now I don't see a clear pathway for us, politically, to pay for it," Congressman Rokita said. "It's going to be your responsibility. I can't think of anything more unfair. We are the first generation to leave the next generation worse off than we were. So what do we do? I need your help. If you don't get involved, then it'll be that much harder to get these changes and you're going to get the bill."

The changes he referenced are reforms to entitlement programs like Medicaid, Medicare and Social Security, which he says were not made for this century. When Social Security was created, Congressman Rokita said, the average American lived to 52, but did not receive benefits until 65. Today, the average American is living to 80 or 90 and receiving benefits at 62.5.

When the floor was opened for questions, the first student asked how he would appeal to young voters. Rokita answered that his presence at the school was part of it, but that no matter who the candidate was, "The question is: Are (the candidates) telling you the whole story? It is a matter of thinking critically, to take in information and compare and contrast it. That is what a free society needs. We can't have engaged robots."

The next question concerned how he felt about Trump's inappropriate remarks. Rokita said that while Trump says things he would not, he is more concerned about why that appeals to voters. He believes they are appealing because voters are angry, and he asked the student what she believes.

"You guys are too scripted," he said.

She agreed voters are angry, and stumbled out her answer to what they were angry about when Congressman Rokita rather impatiently asked for details. He asked another student what she thought, and she mentioned in her answer she was angry about Gov. Mike Pence's attempt to keep refugees out of Indiana.

Congressman Rokita responded that he does not feel confident about taking in refugees considering the government's open admission that it cannot properly investigate each one.

"My first duty is to federal and national security," Congressman Rokita said. "It is not about whether we're being mean."

The next question he answered asked how he would balance the national budget, increase revenue and cut programs. He answered that the U.S. has a spending problem rather than a revenue problem, and the only way to balance the budget is to reform entitlement laws for the next generation.

Another student asked what he would do to improve education issues like student performance testing, teacher accountability testing and wages.

"I would like to pay every good teacher $1 million," he said, "How do you know a bad teacher from a good one?"

He went on to explain how the ESSA is different from the No Child Left Behind Act, and that allowing the free market to work on teachers, parents and competition would naturally select for the best teachers.

The question following asked how he would address racially unequal enforcement of drug and violence laws, which he said he views from a budgetary perspective. He explained that it is a problem for people of any race to have offenders improperly rehabilitated and sitting in prison.

When another female student, the fifth since the first question, stood up to ask her question, Congressman Rokita jokingly asked, "Do the men speak at this school?"

He apologized to the student, but asked to hear from another young man before he left. The student asked how he would limit government over-reach. Congressman Rokita said that "what's really happening now is executive over-reach," but that this is partly Congress's fault for letting decisions, like going to war, go forward without due Constitutional process.

Although some students were not impressed, Rokita did have good things to say about South Putnam High School.

"I have seen the best and the worst of schools," he said. "You are very lucky to be at this school."

View 6 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • Hi! Was Chelsea Modglin or another banner graphic representative present for this visit? I was not present, but these quotations do not reflect what others who were present have said about Congressman Rokita's comments. I would be interested to know if these are quotations from the moment and who was consulted about the students' concerns.

    Stumbling out an answer seems like a pretty understandable response when a congressman accuses you of being scripted after he asks you to prepare your questions in advance so he can look them over.

    -- Posted by Greencastlevoter on Fri, Mar 11, 2016, at 10:45 AM
  • I read this article several times thinking maybe my thoughts were inaccurate. In reading it seems to have a negative connotation, especially against Congressman Rokita. Everyone is entitled to their thoughts and opinions but the newspaper article should not appear to take sides. My child attends SP and attended the Rokita convocation. The questions were vetted by the government teacher and SP Principal, therefore appeared to be scripted because they were. To my knowledge Congressman Rokita did not see the questions prior to his speech. I think it is a valuable experience for the young adults and new voters to hear from our politicians. They need to ask questions and do their homework to determine what they believe is best represented in their politicians. Don't just vote based upon race, gender or some other nonsensical idea. I appreciate Congressman Rokita taking his time to visit with his new constituents. It would be nice to see this occur more often among all political parties and for the Banner to remain unbiased in their reporting.

    -- Posted by SP_Mom on Fri, Mar 11, 2016, at 2:39 PM
  • Based on the fact I was one of the actual students who was a part of this forum, I personally think Chelsea Modglin did the best she could with what comments from students she had to work with. To say the least, the forum was extremely awkward and aggravating. The majority of students were aware of how politics can be going into the forum, but this took the listeners by surprise. Thank you Chelsea Modglin for the time you took on this article, it is greatly appreciated.

    -- Posted by ebunton6613 on Fri, Mar 11, 2016, at 3:00 PM
  • Congressman Rokita asked to be given the questions in advance; whether he indeed read them is something else. Young voters should be afforded the same level of respect as adults-- because that is what they are when they enter a voting booth. Assuming that their questions don't come from their own intelligence or an informed position is a mistake.

    It is important for local and state government to do these sort of events. I'm glad Congressman Rokita chose to do it. But politicians can handle discourse from their constituents. We elected them, after all, and pay their salaries. They work for the people of Indiana.

    -- Posted by Greencastlevoter on Fri, Mar 11, 2016, at 11:50 PM
  • I picked up a negative undertone against Congressman Rokita as well in this article, I think it was good for him to come and great the kids got to ask questions of him, even though they seemed to be slanted to the left rather hard.

    -- Posted by Avenger1234 on Sat, Mar 12, 2016, at 6:35 AM
  • I was on Capitol Hill this week and had an appointment with a member of his staff. The entire office was professional and very warm.

    -- Posted by beg on Thu, Mar 17, 2016, at 11:26 AM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: