Coeds charged in case in which minor had .471 percent BAC

Thursday, February 7, 2019

The Putnam County Prosecutor’s Office has filed charges against two members of a DePauw University sorority for allegedly supplying enough alcohol to a minor male student that he registered a life-threatening blood-alcohol content (BAC) percentage during a party last fall.

Charged with Class B misdemeanors of furnishing alcohol to a minor are Kappa Alpha Theta members Katherine E. Fredrick, 21, Greencastle, (no hometown address available) and Robin J. Hutton, 21, Indianapolis.

Prosecutor Tim Bookwalter told the Banner Graphic charges were being filed against “two DePauw sorority girls who provided alcohol to an underage student waiter,” calling the Nov. 29 incident at the Theta waiter appreciation dinner “some kind of tradition.”

The victim, Gunter Graham Jaeger, 20, was taken to the hospital where he tested a reported .471 percent, a BAC that can be coma-inducing, according to medical sources.

“He could have died,” Bookwalter told the Banner Graphic.

According to information provided by the DePauw Public Safety Office for the probable cause affidavit, the dinner began with a pre-party event on the sundeck at Alpha Tau Omega fraternity, 504 E. Seminary St. Five or six members of Kappa Apha Theta reportedly met there with six male waiters -- two members of ATO and four from Phi Delta Theta fraternity. Four of the waiters were reported as underage.

ATO reportedly allowed the event to occur on its property with Theta providing the alcohol since the sorority cannot consume alcohol at its house at 904 S. Locust St.

The situation came to light when DePauw Capt. Rick Keller responded to the ATO house “after an ambulance was requested for an unconscious intoxicated person.”

Upon arrival, he found Jaeger unconscious in the front passenger seat of a vehicle parked behind the house. Jaeger was extricated by Greencastle firefighters, and transported to Putnam County Hospital by Operation Life ambulance.

ATO President Colin Donahue advised Keller that Jaeger had been at a “sorority dinner” and had been drinking before and during that activity before being driven back to the house by a fraternity brother. At that point no one claimed to know what or how much he had been drinking, Keller reported.

However, officers were dispatched to PCH later that night after reports of Jaeger being combative and disorderly. However, Jaeger was in bed when officers came to speak with him. Keller asked that he contact ATO and tell his fraternity brothers not to come to the hospital.

“When they came out earlier,” Keller noted, “they attempted to get him to leave but his BAC was still a .36 percent. When he came to the hospital his BAC was .471 percent.”

Jaeger reportedly told nurses he had been drinking alone in the basement of ATO, which is how he became so intoxicated.

However, that story took a sudden turn when Jaeger and his father spoke with DPU Public Safety Director Charlene Shrewsbury and Title IX Coordinator Renee Madison of DePauw on Dec. 4, describing what happened at the waiter appreciation dinner that occurs at the end of each semester.

As they were all gathering for the dinner, Jaeger advised, the waiters are supposed to drink before going to Kappa Alpha Theta to eat. When he arrived on the sundeck, he said he saw a handle of Titos Vodka was being passed around before other Thetas arrived with additional alcohol 15 to 20 minutes later.

Jaeger recalls having a handle of vodka in his hand. When he placed it on the ground, a female student (he did not recall who) picked it up and put it back in his hand, telling him “hands on the handle at all times.”

The waiters were also told to get on their knees, Jaeger told DePauw officials, while Thetas poured chocolate syrup and peppermint-flavored vodka in their mouths, creating “Peppermint Patties.” Jaeger said someone on the deck told him bets had been made that he would be the drunkest of the waiters.

Jaeger also said he was contacted by two junior members of the sorority, Robin Hutton and Katherine Fredrick, before the event to ask what he wanted to drink. He told them to buy rum or whatever they wanted, “just not vodka.”

Hutton and Fredrick reportedly purchased moonshine just for him and he was forced to consume it, Jaeger alleged.

Jaeger said he does not recall leaving the ATO house. However, Capt. Keller was able to obtain university video from the Administration Building parking lot showing Jaeger leaving the ATO house with female members of Kappa Alpha Theta on either side of him. A cellphone video taken from inside the vehicle shows Jaeger sitting in the back seat, singing and dancing to music being played. It is apparent the waiter is intoxicated, the affidavit notes.

Jaeger told authorities sorority members took him to their house when they knew he needed to go to the hospital instead. He further said he believes Theta members called ATO to pick him up so an ambulance would not be called to the sorority house.

Between 4:15 p.m. and 5:15 p.m. Jaeger said he was made to consume so much alcohol that he was admitted to the hospital at 6:25 p.m.

Jaeger’s father also advised that ATO members recall his son saying that he told Hutton and Fredrick he had consumed enough alcohol and did not want to drink any more.

As a result of the incident, Kappa Alpha Theta and Alpha Tau Omega have been placed on interim suspension by DePauw.

Comments
View 5 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • *

    Why was the Phi Delta house not similarly placed on suspension? They were involved.

    If 2 fraternities sent 6 waiters (ATO=2, Phi Delta=4) and 4 of them were underage, it goes that at least 2 of the 4 underage drinkers came from the Phi Delta house.

    And its not much of a stretch to assume that the Phi Delta house knew what this "tradition" was about and were party to it. (No pun intended.)

    -- Posted by dreadpirateroberts on Fri, Feb 8, 2019, at 12:00 PM
  • Jaeger's father should have taught his son some drinking skills and we should not be prosecuting these ladies. This is what leads to people not seeking medical help when those at a gathering are being prosecuted. Yes he could have died but help was called this time.

    If DePauw would legalize beer on campus those who over drink should have a lower blood alcohol rather than drinking spirits.

    -- Posted by johnn on Fri, Feb 8, 2019, at 2:43 PM
  • *

    Johnn -

    I have no problem with DePauw being a dry campus, or a wet campus. That is their business to run as they see fit.

    But when you have a group of people that are actively covering their tracks (such as these people did) b/c they didn't want an ambulance to come to their Greek house...B/C THEY KNEW THEY DID SOMETHING WRONG... then yes, they should be prosecuted for BREAKING THE LAW. They intentionally endangered this guy so as to avoid their due punishment.

    (Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.)

    Perhaps you can post your address so that other under-age (ILLEGAL) drinkers can come to you and learn "some drinking skills".

    Just don't be surprised when me, and most other reasonable people, call for you to be prosecuted if you should decide to cover your tracks by endangering someone so as not to be legitimately charged with contributing to the delinquency of a minor, maintaining a common nuisance, and any other laws you may have broken by just trying to teach some under-age adults "some drinking skills".

    -- Posted by dreadpirateroberts on Fri, Feb 8, 2019, at 3:22 PM
  • I'm pretty sure Johnn's reply was either meant as sarcasm, or was a troll post. Or it was a Depauw student, in which case I would really have to question either the quality of individuals they are admitting or the failure of Depauw teaching any critical thinking skills. Or both.

    -- Posted by Koios on Fri, Feb 8, 2019, at 3:50 PM
  • Imagine if it was males who "told [females] to get on their knees"while male fraternity members "poured chocolate syrup and peppermint-flavored vodka in their mouths" and if a female student placed a jug of alcohol on the ground and a male student picked it up and put it back in her hand, telling her “hands on the handle at all times." Let's watch to see if the Title IX Coordinator (sexual harassment) will treat this anywhere close to how it would be treated if the predators were male. As John Oliver would say #feminism

    -- Posted by personal agency on Fri, Feb 8, 2019, at 10:53 PM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: