Cloverdale Schools conducts ALICE training sessions for teachers, staff

Friday, January 24, 2020
School staff overwhelm and throw Nerf balls at mock shooter Tim Savini during the “Counter” exercise.
Banner Graphic/Brand Selvia

CLOVERDALE -- President Theodore Roosevelt has been quoted as saying, “In any moment of decision, the best thing you can do is the right thing, the next best thing is the wrong thing and the worst thing you can do is nothing.”

This mindset set the tone for teachers at Cloverdale Schools as they prepared not to just mitigate an active shooter situation, but to give them and their students the best possible chance to survive.

Staff and administrators from all three schools in the district took a professional day off on Friday to conduct training with ALICE, a program which addresses how to be proactive when faced with such a scenario.

Town Marshal Steve Hibler supervises an exercise showing how an intruder can be taken down and secured by a group.
Banner Graphic/Brand Selvia

ALICE, which stands for Alert, Lockdown, Inform, Counter and Evacuate, is a five-step guide to alerting of a danger, securing in place, communicating an intruder’s location, countering the assailant by distracting them and evacuating the space.

ALICE is not just specific to schools, as government agencies, houses of worship, businesses and health car facilities also participate. The program has more than 31,800 certified instructors with more than one million people trained.

The exercises at Cloverdale were supervised by Town Marshal Steve Hibler and Officer James Collings, who is the student resource officer (SRO) for the school corporation.

Staff previously completed an interactive online course which detailed how the scenarios would be played out in the actual training.

Before the sessions got under way, Superintendent Greg Linton understood the anxiety about the prospect of a school shooting in a time when it has become prevalent nationwide. However, he said it was imperative to prepare for the worst.

“I know this is not a comfortable topic that educators like to talk about,” Linton said. “We have an obligation to do everything we can to make sure we keep ourselves and our students safe.

“The positive is that we can address it now, and that’s why we’re doing this today,” he told everyone.

Linton pointed out that Cloverdale has had an SRO for the past two years, and highlighted the collaborative efforts between the school corporation and the Cloverdale Police Department.

“The marshal and the department have been critical in getting this training set up, and we are fortunate to have a police force which sees us as a community partner,” he said.

The training sessions were condensed into two periods, with two groups assigned to each. The first took place at Cloverdale Elementary School in the morning, while the second was held at Cloverdale High School in the early afternoon.

Hibler provided that the average time for a police force to respond to an active shooter situation is five to six minutes, though some scenarios have found the response time to be as much as 20 minutes.

The town marshal highlighted various shooting scenarios where the “traditional” response to a shooter situation was to stay in place and wait for law enforcement to arrive.

Hibler specifically referenced the 1999 mass shooting at Columbine High School, where groups of students and teachers went on lockdown and hid under tables, even though there were various points of escape.

He also pointed to the 2006 shooting of a one-room schoolhouse in the Amish community of Nickel Mines, Pa., to drive home the importance of being able to counter such an attack.

“You are the first responder here,” Hibler said. “ALICE is designed to empower you all to take action to protect yourselves and your kids.”

Hibler said that people have three natural reactions to stressful situations: Either to fight, to flee or to freeze. As such, the point of the ALICE program is to give teachers and staff the freedom to act as the situation may demand.

The first exercise was the traditional lock-in-place method (including turning off the lights). Groups of staff were relegated to different rooms, with a mock shooter going to each of them with a Nerf gun.

This scenario, which took about five minutes, saw almost everyone getting hit. As the groups debriefed with Hibler and Collings, one teacher said she felt like a “sitting duck.”

The next scenario acted out saw the groups fleeing the classrooms at the sound of an alarm. Even in the chaos which ensued, the number of people who were hit was reduced to a couple of staff members.

“The bad guys are crazy, but they’re not totally stupid,” Hibler said, relating that the intruder in a school shooting scenario would be unwilling to directly confront a stress situation themselves.

He touched on throwing off the shooter’s “OODA (Observe, Orient, Decide and Act) loop,” meaning that the assailant’s focus on a target can be distracted. Yelling is one such deterrent, as was demonstrated in the fleeing exercise.

The groups’ overall confidence in taking control was heightened coming into the last two scenarios, which emphasized barricading entryways as well as directly confronting the shooter.

The groups threw Nerf balls at the mock shooter in the last exercise, though objects such as staplers and coffee cups are certainly not off-limits in a real-life situation. No one reported being hit in this or the barricading scenario.

“If you put up resistance at the door, they’re going to want to move on,” Hibler said in the last debrief. “I hate to put it this way, but they’re looking for how many they can kill quickly before we get there.”

The marshal emphasized that real-time communication was essential. Principal Sonny Stoltz, who is also Cloverdale’s school safety officer, shared that he and other school officials are working to set up a phone app for teachers which immediately alerts law enforcement.

Linton told the Banner Graphic that Cloverdale Schools has emphasized school safety with recently-updated camera systems and improved door access, as well as investing in an SRO. However, he added that the tools and procedures teachers can use need to always be available.

“We want to have consistency between the buildings in the district, and we’ll work on this in the future,” Linton said. “The important thing here is for everyone to be aware of their environment and surroundings.”

Linton assured that new hires who have not completed the online course, as well as those who could not attend the sessions, will be trained prior to the start of the next school year.

The superintendent added that students and parents will soon be briefed on the ALICE program in special community meetings, which will take place at a later time.

View 7 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • Your lead photo seems to show school employees playing in a gleeful manner while someone attempts to shoot people with a Nerf-style gun. Seriously? No. This isn’t serious behavior when teaching about how to respond to a VERY SERIOUS situation. This isn’t something to laugh or joke about even while conducting a mock exercise.

    -- Posted by LJScott on Sat, Jan 25, 2020, at 11:51 AM
  • barnbats...

    Please elaborate and educate on the manner on which any employee that participates in this training should behave. Many safety training's I have participated in could potentially save lives or keep people safe. Fire drill, AED training, and so on. They are all equally important and are intended to educate. Would you be satisfied of looks of anger and more real looking weapon?

    Please send pictures from you place of business participating in a safety training and allow the county to judge facial expressions and mood of participants going through the training!!!

    -- Posted by everyone has an opinion on Mon, Jan 27, 2020, at 8:16 AM
  • *

    Everyone -

    I think the point that barnbats is trying to make is that it doesn't look like the participants are taking this seriously.

    Perhaps it was the nerf balls and toy guns...

    Some law enforcement agencies and some schools use nearly authentic training; such as realistic looking air-soft weapons that shoot plastic bbs that hurt quite a bit when hit with them, and are not only subjected to a fake shooter actively trying to do something (not merely pretending to do something) but have cops yelling and actively clearing the buildings as well.

    Some of these training sessions can be quite intense and stressful. I have heard of teachers and administrators being emotionally shaken during these types of exercises.

    It doesn't seem to be the case here, but maybe it's just bad optics.

    Or maybe they just didn't want that intense level of training.

    -- Posted by dreadpirateroberts on Mon, Jan 27, 2020, at 10:49 AM
  • Thanks to the Cloverdale Police Department for their involvement with the training. Contrary to the stupid comments on here this kind of training is meant to give staff an idea of how to handle things in the unfortunate event a active shooting happens. It also gives them strategies and tools to help them. I for one, do no fault them for being somewhat lighthearted with coworkers role playing. Its like a walk through practice. I am certain the staff took the training to heart and are earnestly serious about this.

    -- Posted by Avenger1234 on Mon, Jan 27, 2020, at 1:05 PM
  • *

    Cloverman -

    Please point out a "stupid comment".

    Barnbats pointed out that from the photo it looks like the staff involved are having a good time and the poster was bothered by the lack of seriousness that the poster believes was warranted. There was nothing stupid about their post. They have a valid opinion even if it may not be yours.

    Everyone has an opinion seems to be coming from the POV that the fact that they are doing drills should be good enough, and chooses to overlook the fact that those training are enjoying themselves. Apparently the lack of realism doesn't bother.

    I was pointing out that the optics will look bad to some (as is the case sometimes with photos), and that there are schools/LEAs that will drill with realism as compared to a more relaxed "walk through" training. But to each their own.

    You have no problem with the "walk through" approach, and your opinion is duly noted. Others (barnbats for example) disagree.

    I think most would agree that whether it is realistic or a simple walk-through, any training is better than no training.

    -- Posted by dreadpirateroberts on Mon, Jan 27, 2020, at 3:08 PM
  • The stupid comments are both of you inferring the teachers are not taking this seriously, based on one photo. So my opinion is that these are stupid and ignorant assumptions to make and both of

    you are doing it to stir the pot, be brazen, and does little to move the dial. I’m sticking with my opinion.

    -- Posted by Avenger1234 on Tue, Jan 28, 2020, at 8:28 PM
  • *

    Thanks, Cloverman, for your opinion.

    Add $2 to that and you could get yourself a cup of coffee.

    I recommend decaf.

    -- Posted by dreadpirateroberts on Wed, Jan 29, 2020, at 12:07 PM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: