Headley one of seven finalists for appeals court vacancy

Thursday, June 11, 2020
Judge Matthew Headley

Following an initial round of interviews that included 13 candidates, Judge Matthew Headley is one of seven finalists for a spot on the Court of Appeals of Indiana.

Headley, judge of Putnam Circuit Court since 2004, is joined in the finalists pool by two other judges and four additional attorneys.

A Greencastle native, Headley was admitted to the Indiana Bar in 1990 following after earning his Bachelor of Arts in 1985 and his Jurris Doctorate and Masters of Business Administration in 1989, all from the University of Mississippi.

He spent time in both private practice and as a deputy prosecutor early in his career before completing two terms as Putnam County prosecutor from 1996-2004.

He is currently four years into his third six-year term as a judge.

The other finalists include Indiana Supreme Court Services Deputy Director Jason Bennett, Morgan Superior Court Judge Peter Foley, Clark County Chief Public Defender Abraham A. Navarro, Vigo Superior Court 2 Judge Lakshmi Y. Reddy, Harrison Circuit Court Judicial Officer Lisa G. Reger and Dearborn County attorney and professor Leanna K. Weissmann.

The vacancy is the result of the retirement of Court of Appeals Judge John Baker this summer. According to the Indiana Constitution and state statute, the seven-member Judicial Nominating Commission must recruit and select candidates to fill vacancies on Indiana appellate courts.

The Commission considers applicants’ legal education, writings, reputation in the practice of law and other pertinent information.

Following the July public interviews (which are expected to be held in person with details to be released soon) the Commission will meet in an executive session and then publicly vote to select the three most qualified candidates and submit them to Governor Eric Holcomb, who has 60 days from receiving the list to select Indiana’s next Court of Appeals judge.

Comments
View 7 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • *

    While I have had my issues with Judge Headley, I do think he tries very hard to be fair and consistent. Having met him several times I have always believed him to be a man of good character.

    I think Indiana could certainly do worse, and I wish Judge Headley luck.

    -- Posted by dreadpirateroberts on Thu, Jun 11, 2020, at 4:21 PM
  • I agree wholeheartedly. I do not always agree with Judge Headley, but I believe he tries to apply the law as written fairly and with some level of empathy.

    -- Posted by techphcy on Thu, Jun 11, 2020, at 8:04 PM
  • I think Matt Headley should go if offered the job and get out of Greencastle. Drive to downtown Indy and work everyday where there might be a little more scrutiny on what he's doing. But I don't see his job performance or personality being at that level, it seems lacking to me for what you would expect a higher court judge. Don't take my word for it, watch him in action at the Putnam County Prosecutor's Roundtable on Youtube. (btw this is the same event where prosecutor Tim Bookwalter calls Putnam Co. the "child molester capital of the world", which I researched and found to be not true at all, Putnam has lower than average sex offenders for child-related crimes per capita locally).

    Maybe the Headley nomination is not because he has some standout resume or character, but because there are several big political players involved in Putnam County, playing politics in local government. The nomination itself is good publicity.

    You have state rep. Beau Baird who is chair of the Putnam co. republican party, and dad is a congressman.

    You also have Rodric Bray, our state senate rep., who is state senate republican majority leader (and is also an attorney, and was a deputy prosecutor in Morgan county around the same time Headley was prosecutor) and former Morgan county republican party chair.

    There's Scott Bieniek, an attorney who seems to have some involvement in local politics. He was part of the team of attorneys who argued for the Citizens United case in the Supreme Court.

    I've also heard from another local attorney that prosecutor Tim Bookwalter is a political player, I guess more than one might expect.

    A few years ago, I had a local attorney tell me Headley leaves his schedule open on Friday afternoon to have lunch with his dad, I guess an early start to the weekend? Then, sometime after that I was in the courthouse to get a copy of some records and witnessed him arrive to work at 10:30 on a Monday. And the court is only open 35 hours a week! But they are so busy they need a magistrate, he said.

    Lakshmi Reddy definitely won't get the job, since she's in the democratic party and republicans are obsessed with controlling the court system with republican judges. She looks qualified but likely on the list for the appearance of it.

    -- Posted by Raker on Fri, Jun 12, 2020, at 7:07 AM
  • Wishing you the best of luck Judge Headley. Quite an honor to be chosen.

    -- Posted by Nit on Fri, Jun 12, 2020, at 12:59 PM
  • Good Luck!

    -- Posted by 1armyvet on Sat, Jun 13, 2020, at 11:44 AM
  • Raker. How many times have you been to the courthouse late at night when court is in session-and Judge Headley is still there? Sounds like you are doing a little nit picking about the hours he keeps when you should be concerned about the service he does for our county.

    -- Posted by Nit on Sun, Jun 14, 2020, at 8:06 PM
  • Actually the more I think about it, whoever gets picked was possibly being decided a long time ago when trying to figure out who would fill the job when baker retired. When I think about the timeline of the magistrate and other events of the last 2-3 years, but I will save my thoughts on for another time. I'm kinda busy right now.

    -- Posted by Raker on Mon, Jun 15, 2020, at 2:10 PM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: