Missed opportunites plague Tiger Cubs in loss

Saturday, September 6, 2008

For a coaching staff dealing with a young team, it's easy to deal in moral victories. When the wins aren't piling up, you try to find the little improvements in losses that show signs of progress.

Greencastle cornerback Ashton Marshall (left) breaks up an Edgewood pass attempt in the first quarter Friday.

While the Greencastle football team showed some of these signs Friday against Edgewood, coach Mike Meyer would have none of it. After the Tiger Cubs' 39-26 loss, he knew his squad could have, even should have, won the game. He made the point clear to his team after the game.

"Edgewood was a good football team and they have an outstanding player. We missed opportunities. We let things go. We missed tackles. We dropped the football. We missed assignments. We had the opportunity to win the ballgame and we didn't take advantage of it," Meyer said.

The Tiger Cubs (1-2, 1-1 WCC) missed countless tackles on the night, particularly in the first half. The Mustang rushers ran through the GHS defense to the tune of 432 yards.

That fact, coupled with GHS's drive-killing drops, made it a wonder that GHS was in the game at all.

The Mustangs (2-1, 1-0 WIC) struck quickly in the first quarter, as quarterback Josh Collier picked up 60 yards and a touchdown on just two carries in the opening drive. A missed extra point by J.T. Finch kept the Mustang lead at 6-0.

Greencastle came back, though, going 35 yards in 11 plays on the way to a 33-yard field goal by Buzz Deer, making the score 6-3.

In the second quarter, though, the missed tackles really began to take a toll. On their first two drives of the quarter, the Mustangs kept the ball on the ground, gaining 67 yards on 10 carries. Both drives ended with Kyle Williams touchdowns and Finch extra points.

It wasn't that the Tiger Cubs weren't getting their hands on Collier and Williams, they just couldn't bring them down.

The GHS offense, for its part, was also struggling. Quarterback Graham Shuee threw a number of nice passes that his receivers could simply not come down with. The issue killed the first two drives of the quarter and led to three-and-outs.

On the third drive of the frame, the offense hit its stride, as Shuee was 3-for-3 for 39 yards and a 25-yard TD strike to Ashton Marshall. The Deer PAT drew the Cubs within 10 with only 1:30 remaining until the half.

But then trouble struck again. On the ensuing kickoff, the Cubs tried an onside kick. Although Deer had the ball in his hands at one point, the Mustangs recovered.

Staring at great field position, they wasted no time. After a short completion to Williams, Collier found Finch on a 49-yard touchdown pass, making the score 27-10 heading into the half.

In the third quarter, the GHS defense continued to struggle from a yardage standpoint. However, the Mustangs only managed to find the end zone once, as Williams scored his third touchdown from five yards out with 1:12 to go in the quarter.

Edgewood led 33-10 after three quarters.

Early in the fourth, the Tiger Cubs had a couple of nice plays to make it a ballgame again. Taking the field for the first time in the game, the Mustang's punt unit looked a little rusty, as the snap sailed over Collier's head and out of the back of the end zone. The safety made it 33-12.

The ensuing free kick gave GHS first-and-10 from their own 42.

On the very first play of the drive, Shuee found Marshall behind the Mustang defense, and the senior sprinted all the way to a 58-yard touchdown, his second scoring grab of the night. Deer's kick made it 33-12 with 11:03 remaining.

After the defense forced another Edgewood punt, Greencastle looked ready to roll again, if not for the injury bug biting again. On an incomplete pass attempt, Shuee was brought down hard and did not get up for a couple of minutes.

Although the senior walked off the field, he did not return to the game.

It was a problem the Tiger Cubs could ill-afford, particularly in the backfield. Starting running back Jordan Hickam went down last week at Speedway and was still out Friday. Likewise, replacement Patrick Richardson had gone down earlier on Friday. The outlooks are mixed for the trio, but Meyer remains positive.

"Hopefully we get Richardson back. I think Graham will be back. Hickam is down for a while, I think," he said. "We'll see what happens. I haven't got all the reports yet, but if they're ready to play, they'll be there to play."

Greencastle defensive linemen Kyle Buchanan and Jacob Wright team up to bring down Mustang quarterback Josh Collier.

In Shuee's absence, the offense struggled. His replacement Tanner Battin was 2-for-5 for 21 yards in the game's final drive, but the offense could not find the end zone again.

Edgewood, on the other hand, had one more score in them, as Williams ran for his fourth touchdown of the night with 3:29 remaining.

The final highlight of the night came from the Greencastle defense. With Edgewood trying to run out the clock, backup QB Kevin Archer fumbled on a rush attempt. Senior defensive lineman Kyle Buchanan scooped up the ball and ran 45 yards for the score.

Deer's last kick of the evening brought the game to it's 39-26 final score.

After the game, Meyer knew his team had lost to a quality opponent, but he still could not get over the chances they had squandered.

"Not to take anything away from Edgewood. The Collier kid is a heck of a player, and it's a good football team," Meyer said. "I'm just disappointed in the missed opportunities. That's all I can say: missed opportunities. And it hurts.

"We saw some good things on offense that we hadn't seen. But, again, we had other chances -- missed tackles, dropped footballs, missed assignments. Those are problems and until we can correct that, it's going to be a bumpy ride," he concluded.

Greencastle visits Triton Central at 7 p.m. next Friday.

At Greencastle

Edgewood6 21 6 6 -- 39
Greencastle3 7 0 16 -- 26

First Quarter

EHS -- Collier 25-yd. run (Finch kick failed) 10:15

GHS -- Deer 33-yrd. FG 5:03

Second Quarter

EHS -- Williams 8-yd. run (Finch kick) 9:59

EHS -- Williams 2-yd. run (Finch kick) 5:44

GHS -- Shuee 25-yd. pass to Marshall (Deer kick) 1:30

EHS -- Collier 49-yd. pass to Finch (Finch kick) 0:56

Third Quarter

EHS -- Williams 5-yd. run (Finch kick failed) 1:12

Fourth Quarter

GHS -- Safety 11:30

GHS -- Shuee 58-yd. pass to Marshall (Deer kick) 11:03

EHS -- Williams 26-yd. run (Finch kick failed) 3:29

GHS -- Buchanan 45-yd. fumble return (Deer kick) 0:27


First downs155


Edgewood (2-1, 1-0 WIC):

Rushing (51 carries, 432 yards) -- Williams 25-210, Collier 17-157, Wagner 4-46, Archer 3-(-2), DuMond 2-20.

Passing (5-11-1-0, 71 yards) -- Collier 5-11, 71 yds., 1 TD, O INT.

Receiving (5 catches, 71 yards) -- Finch 2-56, Williams 1-7, Erwin 1-5, DuMond 1-3.

Greencastle (1-2, 1-2 WCC):

Rushing (20 carries, 40 yards) -- Richardson 9-37, Pettit 5-6, Shuee 4-(-3), Marshall 2-0.

Passing (5-12-2-0, 137 yards) -- Shuee 8-14, 116 yds., 2 TD, 0 INT; Battin 2-5, 21 yds., 0 TD, 0 INT.

Receiving (12 catches, 137 yards) -- Marshall 5-110, Remsburg 4-22, Brown 1-5.

Next game -- Greencastle (1-2, 1-1 WCC) visits Triton Central at 7 p.m. next Friday.

View 3 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • Young Team? This coach has been with these seniors since they were freshman! Maybe it is not the players. Many great athletes chose others sports where coaches are not bullys.

    -- Posted by ghsspirit on Sat, Sep 6, 2008, at 8:33 AM
  • Yes they are young, oh wait they are led by a senior quarterback and have several juniors and seniors that not only have played for GHS,GCMS, but been with some of the coaches through out Youth Football, but oh well just wait till next year, same song differant season

    -- Posted by Trying hard on Tue, Sep 9, 2008, at 9:08 AM
  • don't you guys think that ashton marshall is good at football and basketball? I guarantee you that he is going to get a scholarship to play football sometime this year. he's so hot. I love him a lot and that will never change!!! This is even if he does get a scholarship and even if he does go to college. He's my type and he's so hhoott!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    -- Posted by ghsfreshman on Wed, Oct 8, 2008, at 7:20 PM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: