The Cougars got off to a rocky start as West Vigo's Mike Bucur scored the first goal of the game with 36:16 on the clock.
Things didn't look much better for North Putnam as Chris Boyd pickup up a yellow card with 6:04 remaining on the clock. But the Cougars defense held strong.
In the second half, North got on the board as Dusten Breen scored off an assist from Shin Ryu at the 16:25 mark.
West Vigo answered two minutes later when Trevor Kelsheimer slid a shot past North Putnam's T.J. Whilhite, making the score 2-1 in favor of the Vikings.
With North pushing deep into the Vikings territory, West Vigo committed a foul, setting up Mitch Hadley for a penalty kick. Hadley connected with the ball and sent a blazing bomb past the Vikings keeper to tie the score at 2-all.
"I thought it was a pretty even game," Cougar head coach Dave Moeller said. "I thought we were the better of the two teams. I thought we played well for most of the game. We had more opportunities than them, better opportunities than them. We just didn't finish the ones we had."
When reflecting on the game, Moeller said he thought the team played better but still needs work.
"We've tried to work on defense. This game I thought we did a better job of containing, not stabbing them, playing better team defense this game," Moeller commented.
North will host Crawfordsville at 12 p.m. Saturday.
At North Putnam
West Vigo 1 1 -- 2
North Putnam 0 2 -- 2
West Vigo -- (36:16) Bucur
North Putnam -- (16:25) Breen from Ryu
West Vigo -- (14:25) Kelsheimer
North Putnam -- (3:55) Hadley - penalty kick
Next game -- North will host Crawfordsville at 12 p.m. Saturday.