[Nameplate] Overcast ~ 59°F  
High: 60°F ~ Low: 48°F
Monday, May 2, 2016

Bids on parking garage $1 million or more too high

Saturday, June 15, 2013

An artist rendering of what the downtown parking garage would look like.
It's back to the drawing board -- and perhaps the bank account as well -- for the City of Greencastle's downtown parking garage project.

For all bids on construction of the proposed 146-space parking structure not only have come in overbudget, but the "lowest" of those less-than-magnificent seven proposals was nearly $1 million over estimates. And the highest bid received was nearly $6 million.

The free public parking garage, the biggest single structural element of Greencastle's $19 million Stellar Communities grant package, was figured as a $3,393,529 construction project, according to estimators' estimates, Mayor Sue Murray told the Redevelopment Commission at a special session at City Hall.

"You could have heard a pin drop when they were doing the bid opening," City Attorney Laurie Hardwick said.

The lowest bid received -- $4,387,000 -- was identically submitted by two firms, F. A. Wilhelm Construction and Hageman Construction, both of Indianapolis.

The other five bids on the parking garage project, in ascending order, were:

-- R. L. Turner Construction, Zionsville, $4,895,000.

-- Hannig Construction, Terre Haute, $4,932,000.

-- Weddle Bros. Construction, Bloomington, $5,330,000.

-- Midwest Construction, Indianapolis, $5,700,000.

-- Bulley & Andrews Construction, Chicago, $5,950,000.

Naturally, all seven bids were formally and unanimously rejected by the Redevelopment Commission on a motion by Gary Lemon.

"The architects were very mortified," Mayor Murray told the redevelopment group, which is funding the city's portion of the project through Tax Increment Financing (TIF) funds it administers for the city.

Earlier this spring, project architect Bill Browne of Ratio Architects, Indianapolis, predicted construction on the two-story parking garage would commence in "a July-August timeframe."

The Ratio spokesman indicated a 12-month window was being allowed for construction but Browne said he didn't believe it would take nearly that long to finish the ambitious project.

"We're hoping to complete this faster than 12 months," he said at the time, meaning a late spring 2014 opening was possible.

That, however, seems unlikely now that the bids have been rejected and a rebidding process will be necessary.

"So it'll be what, September?" commission member Gwen Morris asked of a possible construction start.

"I hope not," the mayor responded, remaining optimistic that issues apparently leading to the higher bids could be resolved swiftly via a timely rebidding.

Among issues that reportedly impacted the construction bids were:

-- A misinterpretation of road closure and excavation timing and site requirements of the contractor.

-- Strict adherence to certain restrictions and specifications, some of which the mayor believes can be eliminated from the contract.

-- Extra expenses affecting the overbudget totals by requiring such materials as zinc instead of painted metal in some areas and restricting contractors to a terra cotta exterior that limited builders' material sources.

The public parking garage is to be constructed on city-acquired property bordered by Jackson, Walnut and Indiana streets, just a block from the square.

The structure will provide free parking in the downtown with vehicles entering and exiting only via the Jackson Street side of the garage. Entry will be made via the south end of the Jackson Street side with the exit at the north end of the same side.

Ratio Architects recently unveiled drawings of a building featuring a limestone look and red brick-like accents that was seen co-existing nicely with older, historic buildings in the downtown area.

A series of window openings featuring terra cotta fins have been designed to help provide natural ventilation for the garage interior and allow natural light inside as well.

For the total $4.4 million project (a figure that includes soft costs and property acquisition as well as construction expenses), the city has received grants totaling $3,550,000 and has made application for a $600,000 development loan from the Indiana Housing and Community Development Authority (IHCDA). The Redvelopment Commission will be responsible for that loan, should it be needed to complete the project.

Local match for the parking garage project is $300,000, of which $268,000 already has been expended (including property acquisition costs), the mayor said.

Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. If you feel that a comment is offensive, please Login or Create an account first, and then you will be able to flag a comment as objectionable. Please also note that those who post comments on bannergraphic.com may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.

Why not get DePauw into the act??? They could manage it for the town of Greencastle.

Why not just pave the lot and charge people to park there? Get creative.

-- Posted by donantonioelsabio on Sat, Jun 15, 2013, at 12:08 AM

Apparently, construction firms are so busy they are overbidding on projects. Glad, Greencastle didn't take the bait.

-- Posted by Lookout on Sat, Jun 15, 2013, at 9:23 AM

Clearly the plans and specs were not clear as to what was intended, or the architect was still using prices from a few years ago when contractors were taking any work they could get, even at no profit just to keep their workers busy. Those days are gone now that the economy is recovering from the recession.

-- Posted by VolunteerFF on Sat, Jun 15, 2013, at 11:20 AM

Lets see, 4.4 million dollars for 146 spots equals $30,000 per parking spot - all for a current surface parking lot that is half full at best. Good use of money. Maybe the city can get the same firm that is doing the downtown work - that will insure the garage will be done around 2020.

-- Posted by grassman on Mon, Jun 17, 2013, at 1:00 PM

Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: