Anderson Street to stay one-way

Tuesday, September 19, 2017
East Anderson Street remains a one-way street eastbound between Bloomington and Wood streets, despite a request to the City Council that it be converted into a two-way traffic carrier.
Banner Graphic/ERIC BERNSEE

Despite a 40-signature petition urging the conversion of East Anderson Street in Greencastle from one-way eastbound into two-way traffic between Bloomington and Wood streets, the status quo will prevail.

The Greencastle City Council, during its September meeting, took no action on the petition signed largely by residents of the new Miller Asbury Apartment development at the old Miller School.

“In order to fix a problem,“ City Councilman Gary Lemon said, summarizing the Council stance, “you’ve got to have a problem. And I don’t see one.”

The petition for the change had been hand-delivered to City Hall and Mayor Bill Dory by Carolyn Nichols, representing 40 persons who had signed in support of two-way traffic, ostensibly to simplify access to the Miller Asbury apartments from the east side of town.

Of the 40 signatures, the mayor said 21 were Anderson Street residents (possibly all from Miller Asbury), while 19 others showed addresses elsewhere in Greencastle and even as far away as Cloverdale.

“We received a petition,” Council President Adam Cohen said, “but there is nothing to vote on.”

While no one representing the group requesting the change was in attendance at the September Council meeting, approximately a dozen Anderson Street residents opposed to removing the one-way east designation were there. They presented their own petition, signed by 39 people, all residents of Anderson Street.

Anderson Street resident Dan Merrell represented the group opposed to the suggestion of a two-way traffic change. He reported that 27 of the 33 single-family units along Anderson Street were against the notion.

Of the six remaining units, one is vacant, two couldn’t be contacted despite repeated attempts and three chose to stay neutral on the issue, Merrell said.

“We love our street,” Merrell said of his neighbors. “That’s something rare in today’s society.”

He noted that safety concerns with constant foot traffic through the area, particularly in and out of the Robe-Ann Park entrance, should outweigh the convenience of creating a two-way street.

Mayor Dory said the original petition urging a two-way street was discussed at the city department head meeting recently and public safety personnel all agreed it was better left one-way with parking along only one side.

That alone was enough to convince Councilman Cohen there was no need for change.

“If public safety doesn’t think it’s a good idea, I’m not going to vote for it,” he assured.

Mayor Dory also told the Council he had received an email from Miller Asbury developer Chuck Heintzelman, who “wanted to make it clear it was his residents’ exercising their rights” and not him requesting a change.

The mayor said the developer “knew full well when he did his project that Anderson Street would remain one-way.”

Meanwhile, the Council also approved a number of temporary street closings, the most significant of which is the closing of South Jackson Street between Seminary and Berry streets on Saturday, Nov. 11 during the Monon Bell football game between DePauw University and Wabash College.

DePauw athletic director Stevie Baker-Watson told that Council that a crowd of 8,500 is anticipated for the rivalry game, and many of those spectators will be crossing Jackson Street on foot, creating a safety concern if traffic were to continue at its normal pattern.

The Seminary-to-Berry closing represents a condensed version of what had been presented to the Main Street Greencastle group earlier, City Attorney Laurie Hardwick pointed out. The initial proposal was to close South Jackson between the square and Veterans Highway, she said.

While the Council ultimately approved the Seminary-to-Berry closing for the period 8 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Saturday, Nov. 11, it wasn’t without reservation.

Councilman Mark Hammer said he didn’t like that the closure would go all the way to Berry Street, suggesting that the southern end of the closure be the south end of the parking lots at Blackstock Stadium.

It was also noted that Nov. 11 is, of course, Veterans Day, and the Greencastle VFW Post is located within the South Jackson Street area that will be closed for 9-1/2 hours.

Prior to voting on Councilman Steve Fields’ motion to approve the DePauw closure and traffic plan for the Monon Bell Game, Council President Cohen made an addition to the motion that DePauw must take care of all VFW needs in getting its people in and out of the post on Veterans Day.

The motion passed unanimously.

City Police Chief Tom Sutherlin pointed out that DePauw will be providing the necessary manpower to monitor the intersections and parking lots, not the City Police.

Fire Chief John Burgess said he had no problem with the street closing and how his units will need to navigate around it.

“I’m sure the first time there’ll be some hiccups,” he said, “but we’ll make it work.”

DePauw was also granted permission for the temporary closures of Madison Street, between Hanna and Hill streets, on the west side and Hanna Street, between Indiana and Jackson, from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. on all home football Saturdays of Sept. 23, Oct. 7, Oct. 21, Oct. 28 and Nov. 11.

In another temporary street closing approved, Highridge Avenue from McKim Observatory down and east to Highwood Avenue will be closed for the 10th annual Highridge/Highwood Neighborhood Oktoberfest on Saturday, Oct. 7 (rain date Sunday, Oct. 8) from 4-11 p.m.

View 7 comments
Note: The nature of the Internet makes it impractical for our staff to review every comment. Please note that those who post comments on this website may do so using a screen name, which may or may not reflect a website user's actual name. Readers should be careful not to assign comments to real people who may have names similar to screen names. Refrain from obscenity in your comments, and to keep discussions civil, don't say anything in a way your grandmother would be ashamed to read.
  • The City Council had no problem making Indiana Street south of Hanna a 2-way street to accommodate DePauw's new parking lot.

    -- Posted by Ben Dover on Wed, Sep 20, 2017, at 8:19 AM
  • Ben Dover - sshhh! Someone might think that Greencastle city government is beholden to DePauw University...especially when they all agree to unnecessarily close down access to the VFW on VETERANS DAY to accommodate DePauw for a football game.

    -- Posted by AverageWhiteGuy on Wed, Sep 20, 2017, at 9:24 AM
  • Common sense would suggest there is another reason for the closing of South Jackson St., a major southern route out of Greencastle - The City Council is beholden to Depauw University for anything and everything they want. Isn't the President of the City Council on the staff of Depauw University?

    What has been the problem on previous DPU-Wabash football game days? I haven't heard of any being stated.

    The City Council should revisit this matter, rescind the approval and reopen South Jackson St on this one day.

    -- Posted by Lookout on Wed, Sep 20, 2017, at 11:06 AM
  • This is Adam Cohen. Yes, I am President of City Council and yes, I work for DePauw. All of us on city council have jobs and in a small community everyone knows everyone. At the meeting it was made clear to DePauw as a condition of this passing of the road closing they would: First they will notify the neighbors and second they will work with the VFW to make sure the Veterans day events go on without a hitch.

    Whenever council closes roads for events and we think it will interfere with others we ask the parties to talk. In a small town where people know and live together this has always worked. If it does not work this time, I or another council member will ask that we revisit it next month. Let me also say my email is and you are always welcome to write me. My cell is 765 721 3168. All I can say is I am sorry that any group feels shut out by this process.

    As for Anderson Street, people may come back and present a position. But many of the people who live in the houses there asked that we NOT change it. Nothing to do with DePauw

    -- Posted by Adam Cohen on Wed, Sep 20, 2017, at 1:25 PM
  • One would think it's Monon Bell day, not Veterans Day. I see it as disrespectful to the Veterans that a football game takes presidence over their day.

    -- Posted by Donna Ford on Wed, Sep 20, 2017, at 3:18 PM
  • *

    Adam, I just wanted say "thanks" for taking the time to provide direct feedback about this when you obviously didn't have to. Not many officials do that in today's world (sadly) and it means a lot to people see you do that.

    -- Posted by DouglasQuaid on Wed, Sep 20, 2017, at 7:41 PM
  • I agree with DQ. By the way, making Anderson St a 2 way is a terrible idea for many reasons, I am glad the residents of Anderson St (other than those from Miller Asbury and apparently Cloverdale) came together to agree.

    -- Posted by Koios on Wed, Sep 20, 2017, at 7:48 PM
Respond to this story

Posting a comment requires free registration: